{
  "generated": "2026-09-22",
  "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
  "inspection": {
    "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
    "relation_record_count": 383,
    "relation_lifecycle_counts": {
      "proposed": 383,
      "applied": 0,
      "rejected": 0
    },
    "review_evidence_receipt_count": 2562,
    "review_evidence_note_count": 132
  },
  "nodes": [
    {
      "title": "Classifier-Free Diffusion Guidance",
      "graph_label": "CFG",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jonathan Ho",
        "Tim Salimans"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "diffusion",
        "generative"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
        "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
        "ronnebergerUNet2015",
        "songScoreSDE2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
        "zhangControlNet2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 1
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-04",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 0,
              "confidence": 0.0,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "",
              "evidence_summary": "",
              "generator_version": "",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-04",
              "origins": [],
              "reasons": [],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-04"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-04",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 0,
              "confidence": 0.0,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "",
              "evidence_summary": "",
              "generator_version": "",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-04",
              "origins": [],
              "reasons": [],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-04"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
              "relation": "related",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-04-13",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 52,
              "confidence": 0.52,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "ambiguous",
              "why": "Raw PDF excerpt mentions acronym DDIM for Denoising Diffusion Implicit Models",
              "evidence_summary": "Raw PDF excerpt mentions acronym DDIM for Denoising Diffusion Implicit Models",
              "generator_version": "phase2-v1",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-04-13",
              "origins": [
                "suggest-links"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Raw PDF excerpt mentions acronym DDIM for Denoising Diffusion Implicit Models"
              ],
              "evidence": [
                {
                  "evidence_type": "EXTRACTED",
                  "source_type": "pdf-text",
                  "summary": "Raw PDF excerpt mentions acronym DDIM for Denoising Diffusion Implicit Models.",
                  "confidence": 0.88,
                  "direction": "related"
                },
                {
                  "evidence_type": "METADATA",
                  "source_type": "chronology",
                  "summary": "Candidate year 2020 is prior of target year 2022.",
                  "confidence": 0.58,
                  "direction": "prior"
                }
              ],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-04-13"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 5,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Deep Unsupervised Learning using Nonequilibrium Thermodynamics",
      "graph_label": "Deep Unsupervised Learning using",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jascha Sohl-Dickstein",
        "Eric A. Weiss",
        "Niru Maheswaranathan",
        "Surya Ganguli"
      ],
      "year": "2015",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "diffusion",
        "generative"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "dinhNVP2017",
        "goodfellowGAN2014",
        "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
        "kingmaVAE2013"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
        "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
        "songScoreSDE2020"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-04",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-04",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-04",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-04"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-04",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-04",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songScoreSDE2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-04",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songScoreSDE2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-04"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "metadata": 1,
            "pdf_text": 2,
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Denoising Diffusion Implicit Models",
      "graph_label": "DDIM",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jiaming Song",
        "Chenlin Meng",
        "Stefano Ermon"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "diffusion",
        "generative"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "dinhNVP2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
        "luDPMSolver2022",
        "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 1,
            "related": 1
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-06",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-06",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-06"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 0,
              "confidence": 0.0,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "",
              "evidence_summary": "",
              "generator_version": "",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-06",
              "origins": [],
              "reasons": [],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
              "relation": "related",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-04-13",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 99,
              "confidence": 0.99,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "ambiguous",
              "why": "Raw PDF excerpt cites Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models via Ho et al. (2020)",
              "evidence_summary": "Raw PDF excerpt cites Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models via Ho et al. (2020); Raw PDF excerpt mentions acronym DDPM for Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models",
              "generator_version": "phase2-v1",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-04-13",
              "origins": [
                "suggest-links"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Raw PDF excerpt cites Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models via Ho et al. (2020)",
                "Raw PDF excerpt mentions acronym DDPM for Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models",
                "Title tokens substantially overlap"
              ],
              "evidence": [
                {
                  "evidence_type": "EXTRACTED",
                  "source_type": "pdf-text",
                  "summary": "Raw PDF excerpt cites Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models via Ho et al. (2020).",
                  "confidence": 0.92,
                  "direction": "related"
                },
                {
                  "evidence_type": "EXTRACTED",
                  "source_type": "pdf-text",
                  "summary": "Raw PDF excerpt mentions acronym DDPM for Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models.",
                  "confidence": 0.88,
                  "direction": "related"
                },
                {
                  "evidence_type": "METADATA",
                  "source_type": "title-overlap",
                  "summary": "Title tokens substantially overlap.",
                  "confidence": 0.85,
                  "direction": "related"
                }
              ],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-04-13"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "pdf_text": 2,
            "proposal_relation": 2,
            "tool_call": 15
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models",
      "graph_label": "DDPM",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jonathan Ho",
        "Ajay Jain",
        "Pieter Abbeel"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "diffusion",
        "generative"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
        "dinhNVP2017",
        "ronnebergerUNet2015",
        "songScoreSDE2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
        "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
        "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
        "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
        "luDPMSolver2022",
        "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
        "songScoreSDE2020",
        "zhangControlNet2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 7,
          "proposed_count": 7,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 4,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-05-10",
              "updated_at": "2026-05-17",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-05-16",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-05-10"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-05-10",
              "updated_at": "2026-05-17",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-05-16",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-05-10"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-05-10",
              "updated_at": "2026-05-17",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-05-16",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-05-10"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-05-10",
              "updated_at": "2026-05-17",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-05-16",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-05-10"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-05-10",
              "updated_at": "2026-05-17",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-05-16",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-05-10"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "ronnebergerUNet2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-05-10",
              "updated_at": "2026-05-17",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ronnebergerUNet2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-05-16",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ronnebergerUNet2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-05-10"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-05-10",
              "updated_at": "2026-05-17",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songScoreSDE2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-05-16",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songScoreSDE2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-05-10"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 17,
          "section_count": 5,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Generative Inverse Design of Metamaterials with Functional Responses by Interpretable Learning",
      "graph_label": "Generative Inverse Design Metamaterials",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Wei \"Wayne\" Chen",
        "Rachel Sun",
        "Doksoo Lee",
        "Carlos M. Portela",
        "Wei Chen"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "",
      "tags": [
        "generative",
        "diffusion"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "goodfellowGAN2014",
        "kingmaVAE2013",
        "mildenhallNeRF2020",
        "wuGroupNormalization2018"
      ],
      "further_papers": [],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@GenerativeInverseDesignof2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 4,
          "proposed_count": 4,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 4,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@goodfellowGAN2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@goodfellowGAN2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "kingmaVAE2013",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kingmaVAE2013]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kingmaVAE2013]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-04-13",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@wuGroupNormalization2018]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@wuGroupNormalization2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-04-13"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "pdf_text": 2,
            "proposal_relation": 1,
            "tool_call": 15
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Flamingo: a Visual Language Model for Few-Shot Learning",
      "graph_label": "Flamingo",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jean-Baptiste Alayrac",
        "Jeff Donahue"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "multimodal",
        "vlm"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
        "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
        "liuSwinTransformer2021",
        "radfordCLIP2021",
        "radfordWhisper2022",
        "raffelT5_2020",
        "rameshDALLE2021",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "chameleonTeam2024",
        "liBLIP2_2023",
        "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
        "wuNExTGPT2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@alayracFlamingo2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "liBLIP2_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@liBLIP2_2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@liBLIP2_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 16
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Stochastic Interpolants: A Unifying Framework for Flows and Diffusions",
      "graph_label": "Stochastic Interpolants",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Michael S. Albergo",
        "Nicholas M. Boffi",
        "Eric Vanden-Eijnden"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "flow",
        "generative",
        "diffusion"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
        "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "songScoreSDE2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "songConsistencyModels2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@albergoStochasticInterpolants2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@peeblesDiT2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@peeblesDiT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songScoreSDE2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songScoreSDE2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 19
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Layer Normalization",
      "graph_label": "LayerNorm",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jimmy Lei Ba",
        "Jamie Ryan Kiros",
        "Geoffrey E. Hinton"
      ],
      "year": "2016",
      "venue": "",
      "tags": [
        "normalization",
        "foundations"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "choGRU2014",
        "hochreiterLSTM1997",
        "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "wuGroupNormalization2018"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@baLayerNormalization2016.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "baLayerNormalization2016",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 1,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "baLayerNormalization2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-04-12",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@wuGroupNormalization2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@wuGroupNormalization2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-04-12"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "baLayerNormalization2016",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "choGRU2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@choGRU2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@choGRU2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "baLayerNormalization2016",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hochreiterLSTM1997]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hochreiterLSTM1997]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 16,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 16
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "wav2vec 2.0: A Framework for Self-Supervised Learning of Speech Representations",
      "graph_label": "wav2vec 2.0",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Alexei Baevski",
        "Henry Zhou",
        "Abdelrahman Mohamed",
        "Michael Auli"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "sequence",
        "pretraining",
        "embeddings"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "oordWaveNet2016",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "radfordWhisper2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@baevskiWav2Vec2_2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 1,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "radfordWhisper2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordWhisper2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordWhisper2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "devlinBERT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@devlinBERT2018]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@devlinBERT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 26,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 26
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Neural Machine Translation by Jointly Learning to Align and Translate",
      "graph_label": "Bahdanau Attn",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Dzmitry Bahdanau",
        "Kyunghyun Cho",
        "Yoshua Bengio"
      ],
      "year": "2014",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "attention"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
        "choGRU2014"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "sennrichBPE2016",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@bahdanauAttention2014.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "bahdanauAttention2014",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 16,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 3,
            "tool_call": 13
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Constitutional AI: Harmlessness from AI Feedback",
      "graph_label": "Constitutional AI",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Yuntao Bai",
        "Saurav Kadavath",
        "Sandipan Kundu",
        "Amanda Askell",
        "Jackson Kernion",
        "Andy Jones",
        "Anna Chen",
        "Anna Goldie",
        "Azalia Mirhoseini",
        "Cameron McKinnon",
        "et al."
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "rlhf",
        "rl"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "christianoRLHF2017",
        "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
        "weiCoT2022"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
        "rafailovDPO2023",
        "shaoGRPO2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@baiConstitutionalAI2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 7,
          "proposed_count": 7,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 4,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@lightmanProcessSupervision2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@lightmanProcessSupervision2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "rafailovDPO2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rafailovDPO2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rafailovDPO2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@shaoGRPO2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@shaoGRPO2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@christianoRLHF2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@christianoRLHF2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kojimaZeroShotCoT2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kojimaZeroShotCoT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "weiCoT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@weiCoT2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@weiCoT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 19
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Representation Learning: A Review and New Perspectives",
      "graph_label": "Rep Learning",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Yoshua Bengio",
        "Aaron Courville",
        "Pascal Vincent"
      ],
      "year": "2013",
      "venue": "IEEE TPAMI",
      "tags": [
        "foundations"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
        "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
        "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "goodfellowGAN2014",
        "mikolovWord2vec2013",
        "radfordCLIP2021"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@bengioRepresentationLearning2013.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 6,
          "proposed_count": 6,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 4,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "devlinBERT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@devlinBERT2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@devlinBERT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@goodfellowGAN2014]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@goodfellowGAN2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "mikolovWord2vec2013",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@mikolovWord2vec2013]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@mikolovWord2vec2013]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordCLIP2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordCLIP2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 14,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 12
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Language Models are Few-Shot Learners",
      "graph_label": "GPT-3",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Tom B. Brown",
        "Benjamin Mann"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "transformer",
        "scaling"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
        "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
        "petersELMo2018",
        "radfordGPT2018",
        "radfordGPT2_2019",
        "raffelT5_2020",
        "sennrichBPE2016",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "chameleonTeam2024",
        "chenCodex2021",
        "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
        "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
        "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
        "huLoRA2021",
        "jiangMixtral2024",
        "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
        "shaoGRPO2024",
        "weiCoT2022",
        "wuNExTGPT2023",
        "yaoReAct2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@brownGPT3_2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 4,
          "proposed_count": 4,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 4,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "devlinBERT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@devlinBERT2018]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@devlinBERT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kaplanScalingLaws2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kaplanScalingLaws2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "raffelT5_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@raffelT5_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@raffelT5_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 24,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 7,
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "End-to-End Object Detection with Transformers",
      "graph_label": "End-to-End Object Detection with",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Nicolas Carion",
        "Francisco Massa",
        "Gabriel Synnaeve",
        "Nicolas Usunier",
        "Alexander Kirillov",
        "Sergey Zagoruyko"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "ECCV",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "detection",
        "transformer"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "heMaskRCNN2017",
        "renFasterRCNN2015",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "caronDINO2021",
        "dosovitskiyViT2020",
        "kirillovSAM2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@carionDETR2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "carionDETR2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "carionDETR2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "caronDINO2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-12",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-12",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@caronDINO2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-12",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@caronDINO2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-12"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "carionDETR2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-12",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-12",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-12",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-12"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "carionDETR2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "heMaskRCNN2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-12",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-12",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heMaskRCNN2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-12",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heMaskRCNN2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-12"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 19
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Emerging Properties in Self-Supervised Vision Transformers",
      "graph_label": "Emerging Properties in Self-Supervised",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Mathilde Caron",
        "Hugo Touvron",
        "Ishan Misra",
        "Hervé Jégou",
        "Julien Mairal",
        "Piotr Bojanowski",
        "Armand Joulin"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "ICCV",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "pretraining",
        "transformer"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "carionDETR2020",
        "chenSimCLR2020",
        "dosovitskiyViT2020",
        "grillBYOL2020",
        "radfordCLIP2021"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "heMAE2021",
        "kirillovSAM2023",
        "liuSwinTransformer2021"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@caronDINO2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "caronDINO2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "caronDINO2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "heMAE2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heMAE2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heMAE2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "caronDINO2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "kirillovSAM2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kirillovSAM2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kirillovSAM2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "caronDINO2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@liuSwinTransformer2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@liuSwinTransformer2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "caronDINO2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "caronDINO2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordCLIP2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordCLIP2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 20
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Chameleon: Mixed-Modal Early-Fusion Foundation Models",
      "graph_label": "Chameleon",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Chameleon Team"
      ],
      "year": "2024",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "multimodal",
        "pretraining",
        "generative"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
        "jiangMixtral2024",
        "kirillovSAM2023",
        "lewisRAG2020",
        "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
        "rameshDALLE2021",
        "wuNExTGPT2023"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "jiangMixtral2024",
        "luUnifiedIO2_2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@chameleonTeam2024.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@jiangMixtral2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@jiangMixtral2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "rameshDALLE2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rameshDALLE2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rameshDALLE2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 21,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 21
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Evaluating Large Language Models Trained on Code",
      "graph_label": "Evaluating Large Language Models",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Mark Chen",
        "Jerry Tworek",
        "Heewoo Jun",
        "Qiming Yuan",
        "Henrique Ponde de Oliveira Pinto",
        "Jared Kaplan",
        "Harri Edwards",
        "Yuri Burda",
        "Nicholas Joseph",
        "Greg Brockman",
        "et al."
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "pretraining",
        "scaling",
        "reasoning"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "kaplanScalingLaws2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
        "schickToolformer2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@chenCodex2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "chenCodex2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "chenCodex2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenCodex2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenCodex2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "schickToolformer2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schickToolformer2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schickToolformer2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenCodex2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenCodex2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kaplanScalingLaws2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kaplanScalingLaws2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 27,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 27
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Decision Transformer: Reinforcement Learning via Sequence Modeling",
      "graph_label": "Decision Transformer",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Lili Chen",
        "Kevin Lu",
        "Aravind Rajeswaran",
        "Kimin Lee",
        "Aditya Grover",
        "Michael Laskin",
        "Pieter Abbeel",
        "Aravind Srinivas",
        "Igor Mordatch"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "transformer",
        "sequence"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "haarnojaSAC2018",
        "mnihDQN2015",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
        "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
        "schrittwieserMuZero2020"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@chenDecisionTransformer2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 7,
          "proposed_count": 7,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 4,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV2_2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV2_2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV3_2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV3_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schrittwieserMuZero2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schrittwieserMuZero2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "haarnojaSAC2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@haarnojaSAC2018]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@haarnojaSAC2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "mnihDQN2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@mnihDQN2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@mnihDQN2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 17,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "A Simple Framework for Contrastive Learning of Visual Representations",
      "graph_label": "A Simple Framework Contrastive",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Ting Chen",
        "Simon Kornblith",
        "Mohammad Norouzi",
        "Geoffrey Hinton"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "pretraining",
        "embeddings"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "goodfellowGAN2014",
        "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
        "kingmaAdam2014",
        "radfordCLIP2021"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "caronDINO2021",
        "grillBYOL2020",
        "heMAE2021"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@chenSimCLR2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 7,
          "proposed_count": 7,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 4,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "caronDINO2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@caronDINO2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@caronDINO2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "grillBYOL2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@grillBYOL2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@grillBYOL2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "heMAE2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heMAE2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heMAE2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@goodfellowGAN2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@goodfellowGAN2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "kingmaAdam2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kingmaAdam2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kingmaAdam2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordCLIP2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordCLIP2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 23,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 23
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Learning Phrase Representations using RNN Encoder-Decoder for Statistical Machine Translation",
      "graph_label": "GRU",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Kyunghyun Cho",
        "Bart van Merrienboer"
      ],
      "year": "2014",
      "venue": "EMNLP",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "sequence"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "hochreiterLSTM1997",
        "mikolovWord2vec2013",
        "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "bahdanauAttention2014",
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "haWorldModels2018",
        "petersELMo2018",
        "sennrichBPE2016",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@choGRU2014.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "choGRU2014",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "choGRU2014",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "devlinBERT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@devlinBERT2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@devlinBERT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "choGRU2014",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "petersELMo2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@petersELMo2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@petersELMo2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "choGRU2014",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "choGRU2014",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "mikolovWord2vec2013",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@mikolovWord2vec2013]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@mikolovWord2vec2013]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "choGRU2014",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@sutskeverSeq2Seq2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@sutskeverSeq2Seq2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Deep Reinforcement Learning from Human Preferences",
      "graph_label": "RLHF",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Paul Christiano",
        "Jan Leike"
      ],
      "year": "2017",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "rlhf"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "mnihDQN2015",
        "schulmanPPO2017",
        "silverAlphaGo2016",
        "silverAlphaZero2018"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
        "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
        "rafailovDPO2023",
        "schulmanPPO2017"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@christianoRLHF2017.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 1,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "christianoRLHF2017",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "christianoRLHF2017",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schulmanPPO2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schulmanPPO2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "christianoRLHF2017",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "silverAlphaGo2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@silverAlphaGo2016]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@silverAlphaGo2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 17,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 15
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "FlashAttention: Fast and Memory-Efficient Exact Attention with IO-Awareness",
      "graph_label": "FlashAttention",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Tri Dao",
        "Daniel Y. Fu"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "efficiency",
        "attention"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "suRoFormer2021",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "daoFlashAttention2_2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@daoFlashAttention2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "daoFlashAttention2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 16,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 14
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "FlashAttention-2: Faster Attention with Better Parallelism and Work Partitioning",
      "graph_label": "FlashAttention-2",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Tri Dao"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "attention",
        "efficiency",
        "transformer"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "daoFlashAttention2022",
        "kwonvLLM2023",
        "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "chameleonTeam2024",
        "luUnifiedIO2_2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@daoFlashAttention2_2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 4,
          "proposed_count": 4,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@chameleonTeam2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@chameleonTeam2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "daoFlashAttention2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@daoFlashAttention2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@daoFlashAttention2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 20
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "QLoRA: Efficient Finetuning of Quantized LLMs",
      "graph_label": "QLoRA",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Tim Dettmers",
        "Artidoro Pagnoni"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "efficiency",
        "finetuning"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
        "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
        "huLoRA2021",
        "kwonvLLM2023"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "frantarGPTQ2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@dettmersQLoRA2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "BERT: Pre-training of Deep Bidirectional Transformers for Language Understanding",
      "graph_label": "BERT",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jacob Devlin",
        "Ming-Wei Chang",
        "Kenton Lee",
        "Kristina Toutanova"
      ],
      "year": "2018",
      "venue": "NAACL",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "transformer",
        "pretraining"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
        "choGRU2014",
        "penningtonGloVe2014",
        "petersELMo2018",
        "radfordGPT2018",
        "sennrichBPE2016",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "huLoRA2021",
        "radfordCLIP2021",
        "radfordGPT2_2019",
        "raffelT5_2020",
        "suRoFormer2021"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@devlinBERT2018.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "devlinBERT2018",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 3,
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Diffusion Models Beat GANs on Image Synthesis",
      "graph_label": "ADM",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Prafulla Dhariwal",
        "Alex Nichol"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "generative",
        "diffusion",
        "vision"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "goodfellowGAN2014",
        "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
        "oordWaveNet2016",
        "songScoreSDE2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
        "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
        "luDPMSolver2022",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 1,
          "proposed_count": 1,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songScoreSDE2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songScoreSDE2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 16,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 13
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Density Estimation using Real NVP",
      "graph_label": "RealNVP",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Laurent Dinh",
        "Jascha Sohl-Dickstein",
        "Samy Bengio"
      ],
      "year": "2017",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "generative",
        "flow"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "goodfellowGAN2014",
        "kingmaAdam2014",
        "kingmaVAE2013"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
        "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
        "songScoreSDE2020"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@dinhNVP2017.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "dinhNVP2017",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "dinhNVP2017",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "dinhNVP2017",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "dinhNVP2017",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songScoreSDE2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songScoreSDE2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "dinhNVP2017",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@goodfellowGAN2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@goodfellowGAN2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "dinhNVP2017",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "kingmaAdam2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kingmaAdam2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kingmaAdam2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 16
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "An Image Is Worth 16x16 Words: Transformers for Image Recognition at Scale",
      "graph_label": "ViT",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Alexey Dosovitskiy",
        "Lucas Beyer",
        "Alexander Kolesnikov"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "transformer"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "carionDETR2020",
        "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
        "heMaskRCNN2017",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "caronDINO2021",
        "heMAE2021",
        "kirillovSAM2023",
        "liuSwinTransformer2021",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "radfordCLIP2021"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@dosovitskiyViT2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 16,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 4,
            "tool_call": 12
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Switch Transformers: Scaling to Trillion Parameter Models with Simple and Efficient Sparsity",
      "graph_label": "Switch Transformers",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "William Fedus",
        "Barret Zoph",
        "Noam Shazeer"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "JMLR",
      "tags": [
        "scaling",
        "transformer",
        "efficiency"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "raffelT5_2020",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
        "jiangMixtral2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@fedusSwitchTransformer2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 6,
          "proposed_count": 6,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hoffmannChinchilla2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hoffmannChinchilla2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@jiangMixtral2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@jiangMixtral2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "raffelT5_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@raffelT5_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@raffelT5_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 23,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 23
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "The Lottery Ticket Hypothesis: Finding Sparse, Trainable Neural Networks",
      "graph_label": "Lottery Ticket Hypothesis",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jonathan Frankle",
        "Michael Carbin"
      ],
      "year": "2019",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "foundations",
        "regularization",
        "efficiency"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
        "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
        "srivastavaDropout2014"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "dettmersQLoRA2023",
        "frantarGPTQ2022",
        "powerGrokking2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@frankleLotteryTicket2019.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 6,
          "proposed_count": 6,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dettmersQLoRA2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dettmersQLoRA2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "frantarGPTQ2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@frantarGPTQ2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@frantarGPTQ2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "powerGrokking2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@powerGrokking2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@powerGrokking2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@srivastavaDropout2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@srivastavaDropout2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 21,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 21
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "GPTQ: Accurate Post-Training Quantization for Generative Pre-trained Transformers",
      "graph_label": "GPTQ",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Elias Frantar",
        "Saleh Ashkboos",
        "Torsten Hoefler",
        "Dan Alistarh"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "efficiency",
        "scaling",
        "transformer"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "dettmersQLoRA2023",
        "frankleLotteryTicket2019"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "kwonvLLM2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@frantarGPTQ2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "frantarGPTQ2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 1,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "frantarGPTQ2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kwonvLLM2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kwonvLLM2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "frantarGPTQ2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dettmersQLoRA2023]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dettmersQLoRA2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Generative Adversarial Networks",
      "graph_label": "GAN",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Ian J. Goodfellow",
        "Jean Pouget-Abadie",
        "Mehdi Mirza"
      ],
      "year": "2014",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "generative",
        "gan"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "bengioRepresentationLearning2013"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
        "chenSimCLR2020",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "dinhNVP2017",
        "karrasStyleGAN2019",
        "radfordDCGAN2015",
        "srivastavaDropout2014"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@goodfellowGAN2014.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Bootstrap Your Own Latent: A New Approach to Self-Supervised Learning",
      "graph_label": "Bootstrap Your Own Latent",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jean-Bastien Grill",
        "Florian Strub",
        "Florent Altché",
        "Corentin Tallec",
        "Pierre H. Richemond",
        "Elena Buchatskaya",
        "Carl Doersch",
        "Bernardo Avila Pires",
        "Zhaohan Daniel Guo",
        "Mohammad Gheshlaghi Azar",
        "Bilal Piot",
        "Koray Kavukcuoglu",
        "Rémi Munos",
        "Michal Valko"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "pretraining",
        "embeddings"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "chenSimCLR2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "caronDINO2021",
        "heMAE2021",
        "radfordCLIP2021"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@grillBYOL2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "grillBYOL2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "grillBYOL2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "caronDINO2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@caronDINO2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@caronDINO2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "grillBYOL2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "heMAE2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heMAE2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heMAE2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "grillBYOL2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordCLIP2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordCLIP2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Mamba: Linear-Time Sequence Modeling with Selective State Spaces",
      "graph_label": "Mamba",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Albert Gu",
        "Tri Dao"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "sequence",
        "efficiency"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "hochreiterLSTM1997",
        "pengRWKV2023",
        "suRoFormer2021",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@guMamba2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "guMamba2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "guMamba2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hochreiterLSTM1997]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hochreiterLSTM1997]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "guMamba2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "pengRWKV2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@pengRWKV2023]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@pengRWKV2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "guMamba2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 29,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 29
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Efficiently Modeling Long Sequences with Structured State Spaces",
      "graph_label": "Efficiently Modeling Long Sequences",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Albert Gu",
        "Karan Goel",
        "Christopher Ré"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "sequence",
        "efficiency",
        "foundations"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "hochreiterLSTM1997",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "guMamba2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@guS4_2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "guS4_2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 16,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 16
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Recurrent World Models Facilitate Policy Evolution",
      "graph_label": "Recurrent World Models Facilitate",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "David Ha",
        "Jürgen Schmidhuber"
      ],
      "year": "2018",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "generative",
        "sequence"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "choGRU2014",
        "hochreiterLSTM1997",
        "kingmaVAE2013",
        "mnihA3C_2016"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
        "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
        "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
        "schrittwieserMuZero2020"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@haWorldModels2018.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "haWorldModels2018",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 8,
          "proposed_count": 8,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 4,
            "further_papers": 4,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "haWorldModels2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV1_2019]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV1_2019]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "haWorldModels2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV2_2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV2_2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "haWorldModels2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV3_2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV3_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "haWorldModels2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schrittwieserMuZero2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schrittwieserMuZero2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "haWorldModels2018",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "choGRU2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@choGRU2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@choGRU2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "haWorldModels2018",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hochreiterLSTM1997]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hochreiterLSTM1997]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "haWorldModels2018",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "kingmaVAE2013",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kingmaVAE2013]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kingmaVAE2013]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "haWorldModels2018",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "mnihA3C_2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@mnihA3C_2016]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@mnihA3C_2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 15,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 15
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Soft Actor-Critic: Off-Policy Maximum Entropy Deep Reinforcement Learning with a Stochastic Actor",
      "graph_label": "Soft Actor-Critic",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Tuomas Haarnoja",
        "Aurick Zhou",
        "Pieter Abbeel",
        "Sergey Levine"
      ],
      "year": "2018",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "policy"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "lillicrapDDPG2015",
        "schulmanTRPO2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
        "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
        "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
        "hafnerDreamerV3_2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@haarnojaSAC2018.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "haarnojaSAC2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV2_2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV2_2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "haarnojaSAC2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV3_2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV3_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "haarnojaSAC2018",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@lillicrapDDPG2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@lillicrapDDPG2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 23,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 23
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Dream to Control: Learning Behaviors by Latent Imagination",
      "graph_label": "Dream Control",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Danijar Hafner",
        "Timothy Lillicrap",
        "Jimmy Ba",
        "Mohammad Norouzi"
      ],
      "year": "2019",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "generative",
        "sequence"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "haWorldModels2018",
        "haarnojaSAC2018",
        "lillicrapDDPG2015",
        "mnihA3C_2016",
        "schulmanTRPO2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
        "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
        "schrittwieserMuZero2020"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@hafnerDreamerV1_2019.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 6,
          "proposed_count": 6,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV2_2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV2_2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV3_2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV3_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schrittwieserMuZero2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schrittwieserMuZero2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "haarnojaSAC2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@haarnojaSAC2018]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@haarnojaSAC2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@lillicrapDDPG2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@lillicrapDDPG2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "mnihA3C_2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@mnihA3C_2016]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@mnihA3C_2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 23,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 23
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Mastering Atari with Discrete World Models",
      "graph_label": "Mastering Atari with Discrete",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Danijar Hafner",
        "Timothy Lillicrap",
        "Mohammad Norouzi",
        "Jimmy Ba"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "generative",
        "sequence"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
        "haWorldModels2018",
        "haarnojaSAC2018",
        "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
        "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
        "schulmanTRPO2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "hafnerDreamerV3_2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@hafnerDreamerV2_2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 1,
          "proposed_count": 1,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 1,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV3_2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV3_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 21,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 21
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Mastering Diverse Domains through World Models",
      "graph_label": "Mastering Diverse Domains through",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Danijar Hafner",
        "Jurgis Pasukonis",
        "Jimmy Ba",
        "Timothy Lillicrap"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "generative",
        "scaling"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
        "haWorldModels2018",
        "haarnojaSAC2018",
        "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
        "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
        "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
        "schulmanPPO2017",
        "schulmanTRPO2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@hafnerDreamerV3_2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schrittwieserMuZero2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schrittwieserMuZero2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schulmanPPO2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schulmanPPO2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 19
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Inductive Representation Learning on Large Graphs",
      "graph_label": "Inductive Representation Learning on",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "William L. Hamilton",
        "Rex Ying",
        "Jure Leskovec"
      ],
      "year": "2017",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "graph",
        "embeddings"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "kipfGCN2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "velickovicGAT2018"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@hamiltonGraphSAGE2017.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "hamiltonGraphSAGE2017",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 17,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Deep Residual Learning for Image Recognition",
      "graph_label": "ResNet",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Kaiming He",
        "Xiangyu Zhang",
        "Shaoqing Ren",
        "Jian Sun"
      ],
      "year": "2016",
      "venue": "IEEE",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "cnn",
        "foundations"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "heKaimingInit2015",
        "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
        "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
        "srivastavaDropout2014",
        "szegedyGoogLeNet2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "chenSimCLR2020",
        "dosovitskiyViT2020",
        "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
        "heMaskRCNN2017",
        "huangDenseNet2017",
        "tanEfficientNet2019"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@heDeepResidualLearning2016.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 4,
          "proposed_count": 4,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 4,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "heMaskRCNN2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heMaskRCNN2017]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heMaskRCNN2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "huangDenseNet2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@huangDenseNet2017]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@huangDenseNet2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "tanEfficientNet2019",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@tanEfficientNet2019]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@tanEfficientNet2019]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 13,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 13
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Delving Deep into Rectifiers: Surpassing Human-Level Performance on ImageNet Classification",
      "graph_label": "He Init",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Kaiming He",
        "Xiangyu Zhang",
        "Shaoqing Ren",
        "Jian Sun"
      ],
      "year": "2015",
      "venue": "ICCV",
      "tags": [
        "optimization",
        "initialization"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
        "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
        "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
        "szegedyGoogLeNet2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
        "huangDenseNet2017",
        "tanEfficientNet2019"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@heKaimingInit2015.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 6,
          "proposed_count": 6,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "huangDenseNet2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@huangDenseNet2017]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@huangDenseNet2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "tanEfficientNet2019",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@tanEfficientNet2019]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@tanEfficientNet2019]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@szegedyGoogLeNet2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@szegedyGoogLeNet2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 16,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 14
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Masked Autoencoders Are Scalable Vision Learners",
      "graph_label": "Masked Autoencoders Are Scalable",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Kaiming He",
        "Xinlei Chen",
        "Saining Xie",
        "Yanghao Li",
        "Piotr Dollár",
        "Ross Girshick"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "CVPR",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "pretraining",
        "transformer"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "caronDINO2021",
        "chenSimCLR2020",
        "dosovitskiyViT2020",
        "grillBYOL2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "kirillovSAM2023",
        "liuSwinTransformer2021",
        "peeblesDiT2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@heMAE2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "heMAE2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 4,
          "proposed_count": 4,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "heMAE2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "kirillovSAM2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kirillovSAM2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kirillovSAM2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heMAE2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@liuSwinTransformer2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@liuSwinTransformer2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heMAE2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@peeblesDiT2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@peeblesDiT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heMAE2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 19
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Mask R-CNN",
      "graph_label": "Mask R-CNN",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Kaiming He",
        "Georgia Gkioxari",
        "Piotr Dollar",
        "Ross Girshick"
      ],
      "year": "2017",
      "venue": "ICCV",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "segmentation",
        "detection"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
        "redmonYOLO2016",
        "renFasterRCNN2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "carionDETR2020",
        "dosovitskiyViT2020",
        "kirillovSAM2023",
        "liuSwinTransformer2021"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@heMaskRCNN2017.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "heMaskRCNN2017",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heMaskRCNN2017",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@liuSwinTransformer2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@liuSwinTransformer2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "heMaskRCNN2017",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Momentum Contrast for Unsupervised Visual Representation Learning",
      "graph_label": "Momentum Contrast Unsupervised Visual",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Kaiming He",
        "Haoqi Fan",
        "Yuxin Wu",
        "Saining Xie",
        "Ross Girshick"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "CVPR",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "pretraining",
        "embeddings"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "heDeepResidualLearning2016"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "chenSimCLR2020",
        "grillBYOL2020"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@heMoCo2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "heMoCo2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 20
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "A Fast Learning Algorithm for Deep Belief Nets",
      "graph_label": "DBN",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Geoffrey E. Hinton",
        "Simon Osindero",
        "Yee-Whye Teh"
      ],
      "year": "2006",
      "venue": "Neural Computation",
      "tags": [
        "foundations",
        "generative"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
        "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
        "hintonDistillation2015"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@hintonDeepBeliefNets2006.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Distilling the Knowledge in a Neural Network",
      "graph_label": "Distilling Knowledge in a",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Geoffrey Hinton",
        "Oriol Vinyals",
        "Jeff Dean"
      ],
      "year": "2015",
      "venue": "NeurIPS Workshop",
      "tags": [
        "efficiency",
        "foundations"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
        "srivastavaDropout2014"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
        "songConsistencyModels2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@hintonDistillation2015.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "hintonDistillation2015",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "hintonDistillation2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hintonDistillation2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hintonDistillation2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hintonDistillation2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hintonDeepBeliefNets2006]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hintonDeepBeliefNets2006]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hintonDistillation2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@srivastavaDropout2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@srivastavaDropout2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 11,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 11
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Video Diffusion Models",
      "graph_label": "Video Diffusion Models",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jonathan Ho",
        "Tim Salimans",
        "Alexey Gritsenko",
        "William Chan",
        "Mohammad Norouzi",
        "David J. Fleet"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "diffusion",
        "generative",
        "vision"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
        "oordWaveNet2016",
        "songScoreSDE2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
        "songConsistencyModels2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@hoVideoDiffusion2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 8,
          "proposed_count": 8,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 4,
            "further_papers": 4,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "karrasEDM2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@karrasEDM2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@karrasEDM2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@peeblesDiT2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@peeblesDiT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songScoreSDE2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songScoreSDE2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 17,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Long Short-Term Memory",
      "graph_label": "LSTM",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Sepp Hochreiter",
        "Jurgen Schmidhuber"
      ],
      "year": "1997",
      "venue": "Neural Computation",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "sequence"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "choGRU2014",
        "guMamba2023",
        "haWorldModels2018",
        "pengRWKV2023",
        "petersELMo2018",
        "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@hochreiterLSTM1997.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 23,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 4,
            "tool_call": 19
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Training Compute-Optimal Large Language Models",
      "graph_label": "Chinchilla",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jordan Hoffmann",
        "Sebastian Borgeaud"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "DeepMind",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "scaling"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
        "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
        "radfordGPT2_2019",
        "raffelT5_2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "dettmersQLoRA2023",
        "jiangMixtral2024",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@hoffmannChinchilla2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-06",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-06",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-06"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-06",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dettmersQLoRA2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-06",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dettmersQLoRA2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-06"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-06",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-06",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-06"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "The Curious Case of Neural Text Degeneration",
      "graph_label": "Curious Case Neural Text",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Ari Holtzman",
        "Jan Buys",
        "Li Du",
        "Maxwell Forbes",
        "Yejin Choi"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "sequence",
        "generative"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "radfordGPT2_2019",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
        "rafailovDPO2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@holtzmanNucleusSampling2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 6,
          "proposed_count": 6,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 4,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "rafailovDPO2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rafailovDPO2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rafailovDPO2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "radfordGPT2_2019",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordGPT2_2019]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordGPT2_2019]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 26,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 26
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "LoRA: Low-Rank Adaptation of Large Language Models",
      "graph_label": "LoRA",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Edward J. Hu",
        "Yelong Shen"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "efficiency",
        "finetuning"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "dettmersQLoRA2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@huLoRA2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "huLoRA2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "huLoRA2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "devlinBERT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@devlinBERT2018]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@devlinBERT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "huLoRA2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 14,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "tool_call": 12
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Densely Connected Convolutional Networks",
      "graph_label": "DenseNet",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Gao Huang",
        "Zhuang Liu",
        "Laurens van der Maaten",
        "Kilian Q. Weinberger"
      ],
      "year": "2017",
      "venue": "CVPR",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "cnn"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
        "heKaimingInit2015",
        "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
        "szegedyGoogLeNet2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "tanEfficientNet2019"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@huangDenseNet2017.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "huangDenseNet2017",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Batch Normalization: Accelerating Deep Network Training by Reducing Internal Covariate Shift",
      "graph_label": "BatchNorm",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Sergey Ioffe",
        "Christian Szegedy"
      ],
      "year": "2015",
      "venue": "",
      "tags": [
        "normalization",
        "foundations"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "heKaimingInit2015",
        "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
        "srivastavaDropout2014",
        "szegedyGoogLeNet2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "baLayerNormalization2016",
        "heKaimingInit2015",
        "ulyanovInstanceNormalizationMissing2017",
        "wuGroupNormalization2018"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 6,
          "proposed_count": 6,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 4,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "baLayerNormalization2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-04-12",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@baLayerNormalization2016]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@baLayerNormalization2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-04-12"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-04-12",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@wuGroupNormalization2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@wuGroupNormalization2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-04-12"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "heKaimingInit2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heKaimingInit2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heKaimingInit2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@krizhevskyAlexNet2012]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@krizhevskyAlexNet2012]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@srivastavaDropout2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@srivastavaDropout2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@szegedyGoogLeNet2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@szegedyGoogLeNet2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 12,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 12
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Mixtral of Experts",
      "graph_label": "Mixtral Experts",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Albert Q. Jiang",
        "Alexandre Sablayrolles",
        "Antoine Roux",
        "Arthur Mensch",
        "Blanche Savary",
        "Chris Bamford",
        "Devendra Singh Chaplot",
        "Diego de las Casas",
        "Emma Bou Hanna",
        "Florian Bressand",
        "et al."
      ],
      "year": "2024",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "scaling",
        "transformer",
        "efficiency"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "chameleonTeam2024",
        "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
        "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
        "kwonvLLM2023",
        "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "chameleonTeam2024",
        "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
        "shaoGRPO2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@jiangMixtral2024.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 6,
          "proposed_count": 6,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@chameleonTeam2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@chameleonTeam2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@shaoGRPO2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@shaoGRPO2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hoffmannChinchilla2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hoffmannChinchilla2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 17,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Scaling Laws for Neural Language Models",
      "graph_label": "Scaling Laws",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jared Kaplan",
        "Sam McCandlish"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "OpenAI",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "scaling"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "radfordGPT2_2019",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "chenCodex2021",
        "hoffmannChinchilla2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@kaplanScalingLaws2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 1,
          "proposed_count": 1,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Elucidating the Design Space of Diffusion-Based Generative Models",
      "graph_label": "Elucidating Design Space Diffusion-Based",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Tero Karras",
        "Miika Aittala",
        "Timo Aila",
        "Samuli Laine"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "diffusion",
        "generative"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
        "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
        "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
        "luDPMSolver2022",
        "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "songScoreSDE2020",
        "zhangControlNet2023"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "songConsistencyModels2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@karrasEDM2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "karrasEDM2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 7,
          "proposed_count": 7,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 4,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "karrasEDM2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@albergoStochasticInterpolants2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@albergoStochasticInterpolants2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "karrasEDM2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@peeblesDiT2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@peeblesDiT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "karrasEDM2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "karrasEDM2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "karrasEDM2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "karrasEDM2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "karrasEDM2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songScoreSDE2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songScoreSDE2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 24,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 24
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "A Style-Based Generator Architecture for Generative Adversarial Networks",
      "graph_label": "StyleGAN",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Tero Karras",
        "Samuli Laine",
        "Timo Aila"
      ],
      "year": "2019",
      "venue": "CVPR",
      "tags": [
        "generative",
        "gan",
        "vision"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "goodfellowGAN2014",
        "radfordDCGAN2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@karrasStyleGAN2019.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "karrasStyleGAN2019",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 1,
          "proposed_count": 1,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "karrasStyleGAN2019",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@goodfellowGAN2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@goodfellowGAN2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 15,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 13
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "3D Gaussian Splatting for Real-Time Radiance Field Rendering",
      "graph_label": "3D Gaussian Splatting Real-Time",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Bernhard Kerbl",
        "Georgios Kopanas",
        "Thomas Leimkühler",
        "George Drettakis"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "SIGGRAPH",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "generative",
        "efficiency"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "mildenhallNeRF2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@kerblGaussianSplatting2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "kerblGaussianSplatting2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 22,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 22
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Adam: A Method for Stochastic Optimization",
      "graph_label": "Adam",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Diederik P. Kingma",
        "Jimmy Ba"
      ],
      "year": "2014",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "optimization"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [],
      "further_papers": [
        "chenSimCLR2020",
        "dinhNVP2017",
        "loshchilovAdamW2019"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@kingmaAdam2014.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "kingmaAdam2014",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 16
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Auto-Encoding Variational Bayes",
      "graph_label": "VAE",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Diederik P. Kingma",
        "Max Welling"
      ],
      "year": "2013",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "generative",
        "vae"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [],
      "further_papers": [
        "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
        "dinhNVP2017",
        "haWorldModels2018",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@kingmaVAE2013.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "kingmaVAE2013",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 15,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 12
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Semi-Supervised Classification with Graph Convolutional Networks",
      "graph_label": "Semi-Supervised Classification with Graph",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Thomas N. Kipf",
        "Max Welling"
      ],
      "year": "2017",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "graph",
        "foundations"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [],
      "further_papers": [
        "hamiltonGraphSAGE2017",
        "velickovicGAT2018"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@kipfGCN2017.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "kipfGCN2017",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 22,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 22
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Segment Anything",
      "graph_label": "Segment Anything",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Alexander Kirillov",
        "Eric Mintun",
        "Nikhila Ravi",
        "Hanzi Mao",
        "Chloe Rolland",
        "Laura Gustafson",
        "Tete Xiao",
        "Spencer Whitehead",
        "Alexander C. Berg",
        "Wan-Yen Lo",
        "Piotr Dollár",
        "Ross Girshick"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "ICCV",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "segmentation",
        "foundations"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "caronDINO2021",
        "dosovitskiyViT2020",
        "heMAE2021",
        "heMaskRCNN2017",
        "radfordCLIP2021"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "chameleonTeam2024",
        "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
        "wuNExTGPT2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@kirillovSAM2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 6,
          "proposed_count": 6,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@chameleonTeam2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@chameleonTeam2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "wuNExTGPT2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@wuNExTGPT2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@wuNExTGPT2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "heMaskRCNN2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heMaskRCNN2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heMaskRCNN2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordCLIP2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordCLIP2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 20
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Large Language Models are Zero-Shot Reasoners",
      "graph_label": "Zero-Shot CoT",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Takeshi Kojima",
        "Shixiang Shane Gu"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "reasoning"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
        "weiCoT2022"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
        "yaoReAct2022",
        "yaoToT2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@kojimaZeroShotCoT2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "ImageNet Classification with Deep Convolutional Neural Networks",
      "graph_label": "AlexNet",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Alex Krizhevsky",
        "Ilya Sutskever",
        "Geoffrey E. Hinton"
      ],
      "year": "2012",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "cnn"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
        "srivastavaDropout2014"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "heKaimingInit2015",
        "mnihDQN2015",
        "radfordDCGAN2015",
        "renFasterRCNN2015",
        "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
        "srivastavaDropout2014",
        "szegedyGoogLeNet2015"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@krizhevskyAlexNet2012.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 1,
          "proposed_count": 1,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@srivastavaDropout2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@srivastavaDropout2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 22,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 8,
            "tool_call": 14
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Efficient Memory Management for Large Language Model Serving with PagedAttention",
      "graph_label": "Efficient Memory Management Large",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Woosuk Kwon",
        "Zhuohan Li",
        "Siyuan Zhuang",
        "Ying Sheng",
        "Lianmin Zheng",
        "Cody Hao Yu",
        "Joseph E. Gonzalez",
        "Hao Zhang",
        "Ion Stoica"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "SOSP",
      "tags": [
        "efficiency",
        "scaling",
        "attention"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "frantarGPTQ2022",
        "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
        "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
        "schickToolformer2023",
        "yaoToT2023"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
        "dettmersQLoRA2023",
        "jiangMixtral2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@kwonvLLM2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "kwonvLLM2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@daoFlashAttention2_2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@daoFlashAttention2_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "kwonvLLM2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dettmersQLoRA2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dettmersQLoRA2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "kwonvLLM2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@jiangMixtral2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@jiangMixtral2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 27,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 27
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Gradient-based learning applied to document recognition",
      "graph_label": "LeNet",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Y. Lecun",
        "L. Bottou",
        "Y. Bengio",
        "P. Haffner"
      ],
      "year": "1998",
      "venue": "Proceedings of the IEEE",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "cnn",
        "foundations"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "rosenblattPerceptron1958",
        "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
        "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
        "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
        "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
        "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-04-12",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-04-12"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@krizhevskyAlexNet2012]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@krizhevskyAlexNet2012]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "rosenblattPerceptron1958",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rosenblattPerceptron1958]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rosenblattPerceptron1958]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 14,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "metadata": 1,
            "proposal_relation": 1,
            "tool_call": 12
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Fast Inference from Transformers via Speculative Decoding",
      "graph_label": "Fast Inference from Transformers",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Yaniv Leviathan",
        "Matan Kalman",
        "Yossi Matias"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "efficiency",
        "transformer"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "chenCodex2021",
        "hintonDistillation2015",
        "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
        "jiangMixtral2024",
        "kwonvLLM2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@daoFlashAttention2_2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@daoFlashAttention2_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@jiangMixtral2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@jiangMixtral2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kwonvLLM2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kwonvLLM2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 25,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 25
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Knowledge-Intensive NLP Tasks",
      "graph_label": "Retrieval-Augmented Generation Knowledge-Intensive NLP",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Patrick Lewis",
        "Ethan Perez",
        "Aleksandra Piktus",
        "Fabio Petroni",
        "Vladimir Karpukhin",
        "Naman Goyal",
        "Heinrich Küttler",
        "Mike Lewis",
        "Wen-tau Yih",
        "Tim Rocktäschel",
        "Sebastian Riedel",
        "Douwe Kiela"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "search",
        "pretraining",
        "reasoning"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "raffelT5_2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "chameleonTeam2024",
        "schickToolformer2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@lewisRAG2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "lewisRAG2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "lewisRAG2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@chameleonTeam2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@chameleonTeam2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lewisRAG2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "schickToolformer2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schickToolformer2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schickToolformer2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lewisRAG2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "raffelT5_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@raffelT5_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@raffelT5_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 20
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "BLIP-2: Bootstrapping Language-Image Pre-training with Frozen Image Encoders and Large Language Models",
      "graph_label": "BLIP-2",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Junnan Li",
        "Dongxu Li"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "multimodal",
        "vlm"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "liuSwinTransformer2021",
        "radfordCLIP2021",
        "rameshDALLE2021"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
        "wuNExTGPT2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@liBLIP2_2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 21,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 19
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Let's Verify Step by Step",
      "graph_label": "Let's Verify Step Step",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Hunter Lightman",
        "Vineet Kosaraju",
        "Yura Burda",
        "Harri Edwards",
        "Bowen Baker",
        "Teddy Lee",
        "Jan Leike",
        "John Schulman",
        "Ilya Sutskever",
        "Karl Cobbe"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "rlhf",
        "reasoning"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
        "christianoRLHF2017",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
        "yaoToT2023"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "kwonvLLM2023",
        "rafailovDPO2023",
        "shaoGRPO2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@lightmanProcessSupervision2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kwonvLLM2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kwonvLLM2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "rafailovDPO2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rafailovDPO2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rafailovDPO2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@shaoGRPO2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@shaoGRPO2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@christianoRLHF2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@christianoRLHF2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 19
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Continuous control with deep reinforcement learning",
      "graph_label": "Continuous control with deep",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Timothy P. Lillicrap",
        "Jonathan J. Hunt",
        "Alexander Pritzel",
        "Nicolas Heess",
        "Tom Erez",
        "Yuval Tassa",
        "David Silver",
        "Daan Wierstra"
      ],
      "year": "2015",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "policy"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "mnihDQN2015",
        "schulmanTRPO2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "haarnojaSAC2018",
        "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
        "mnihA3C_2016",
        "schulmanTRPO2015"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@lillicrapDDPG2015.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "mnihDQN2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@mnihDQN2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@mnihDQN2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "schulmanTRPO2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schulmanTRPO2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schulmanTRPO2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 25,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 25
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Flow Matching for Generative Modeling",
      "graph_label": "Flow Matching Generative Modeling",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Yaron Lipman",
        "Ricky T. Q. Chen",
        "Heli Ben-Hamu",
        "Maximilian Nickel",
        "Matt Le"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "flow",
        "generative",
        "diffusion"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "dinhNVP2017",
        "songScoreSDE2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
        "songConsistencyModels2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@lipmanFlowMatching2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 8,
          "proposed_count": 8,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 4,
            "further_papers": 4,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@albergoStochasticInterpolants2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@albergoStochasticInterpolants2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "karrasEDM2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@karrasEDM2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@karrasEDM2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@liuRectifiedFlow2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@liuRectifiedFlow2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "dinhNVP2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dinhNVP2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dinhNVP2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songScoreSDE2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songScoreSDE2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 20
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Flow Straight and Fast: Learning to Generate and Transfer Data with Rectified Flow",
      "graph_label": "Flow Straight Fast",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Xingchao Liu",
        "Chengyue Gong",
        "Qiang Liu"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "flow",
        "generative"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
        "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
        "songScoreSDE2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "songConsistencyModels2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@liuRectifiedFlow2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@albergoStochasticInterpolants2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@albergoStochasticInterpolants2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "karrasEDM2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@karrasEDM2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@karrasEDM2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songScoreSDE2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songScoreSDE2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 15,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 15
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Swin Transformer: Hierarchical Vision Transformer using Shifted Windows",
      "graph_label": "Swin",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Ze Liu",
        "Yutong Lin",
        "Yue Cao"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "ICCV",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "transformer"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "caronDINO2021",
        "dosovitskiyViT2020",
        "heMAE2021",
        "heMaskRCNN2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "liBLIP2_2023",
        "radfordCLIP2021"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@liuSwinTransformer2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "liBLIP2_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@liBLIP2_2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@liBLIP2_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordCLIP2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordCLIP2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 16
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Decoupled Weight Decay Regularization",
      "graph_label": "AdamW",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Ilya Loshchilov",
        "Frank Hutter"
      ],
      "year": "2019",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "optimization",
        "regularization"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "kingmaAdam2014"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "powerGrokking2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@loshchilovAdamW2019.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "loshchilovAdamW2019",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 16
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "DPM-Solver: A Fast ODE Solver for Diffusion Probabilistic Model Sampling in Around 10 Steps",
      "graph_label": "DPM-Solver",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Cheng Lu",
        "Yuhao Zhou",
        "Fan Bao",
        "Jianfei Chen",
        "Chongxuan Li",
        "Jun Zhu"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "diffusion",
        "efficiency"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
        "songScoreSDE2020",
        "zhangControlNet2023"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
        "songConsistencyModels2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@luDPMSolver2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 9,
          "proposed_count": 9,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 5,
            "further_papers": 4,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "karrasEDM2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@karrasEDM2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@karrasEDM2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@peeblesDiT2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@peeblesDiT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songScoreSDE2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songScoreSDE2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 22,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 22
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Unified-IO 2: Scaling Autoregressive Multimodal Models with Vision, Language, Audio, and Action",
      "graph_label": "Unified-IO 2",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jiasen Lu",
        "Christopher Clark",
        "Sangho Lee",
        "Zichen Zhang",
        "Savya Khosla",
        "Ryan Marten",
        "Derek Hoiem",
        "Aniruddha Kembhavi"
      ],
      "year": "2024",
      "venue": "CVPR",
      "tags": [
        "multimodal",
        "scaling",
        "generative"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "chameleonTeam2024",
        "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
        "jiangMixtral2024",
        "kirillovSAM2023",
        "liBLIP2_2023",
        "radfordWhisper2022",
        "raffelT5_2020",
        "rameshDALLE2021",
        "schickToolformer2023",
        "wuNExTGPT2023"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "chameleonTeam2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@luUnifiedIO2_2024.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 4,
            "further_papers": 1,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@chameleonTeam2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@chameleonTeam2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "liBLIP2_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@liBLIP2_2023]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@liBLIP2_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "raffelT5_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@raffelT5_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@raffelT5_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "rameshDALLE2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rameshDALLE2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rameshDALLE2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 23,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 23
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Efficient Estimation of Word Representations in Vector Space",
      "graph_label": "Word2Vec",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Tomas Mikolov",
        "Kai Chen",
        "Greg Corrado",
        "Jeffrey Dean"
      ],
      "year": "2013",
      "venue": "ICLR Workshop",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "embeddings"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "bengioRepresentationLearning2013"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "choGRU2014",
        "penningtonGloVe2014",
        "petersELMo2018"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@mikolovWord2vec2013.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "mikolovWord2vec2013",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 16,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 13
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "NeRF: Representing Scenes as Neural Radiance Fields for View Synthesis",
      "graph_label": "NeRF",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Ben Mildenhall",
        "Pratul P. Srinivasan",
        "Matthew Tancik",
        "Jonathan T. Barron",
        "Ravi Ramamoorthi",
        "Ren Ng"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "ECCV",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "generative",
        "foundations"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [],
      "further_papers": [
        "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
        "kerblGaussianSplatting2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@mildenhallNeRF2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "mildenhallNeRF2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "mildenhallNeRF2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@GenerativeInverseDesignof2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@GenerativeInverseDesignof2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "mildenhallNeRF2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "kerblGaussianSplatting2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kerblGaussianSplatting2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kerblGaussianSplatting2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 23,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 23
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Asynchronous Methods for Deep Reinforcement Learning",
      "graph_label": "Asynchronous Methods Deep Reinforcement",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Volodymyr Mnih",
        "Adrià Puigdomènech Badia",
        "Mehdi Mirza",
        "Alex Graves",
        "Timothy Lillicrap",
        "Tim Harley",
        "David Silver",
        "Koray Kavukcuoglu"
      ],
      "year": "2016",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "policy"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "lillicrapDDPG2015",
        "mnihDQN2015",
        "schulmanTRPO2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "haWorldModels2018",
        "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
        "schulmanTRPO2015"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@mnihA3C_2016.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "mnihA3C_2016",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@lillicrapDDPG2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@lillicrapDDPG2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "mnihA3C_2016",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "mnihDQN2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@mnihDQN2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@mnihDQN2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "mnihA3C_2016",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "schulmanTRPO2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schulmanTRPO2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schulmanTRPO2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 25,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 25
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Human-Level Control through Deep Reinforcement Learning",
      "graph_label": "DQN",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Volodymyr Mnih",
        "Koray Kavukcuoglu"
      ],
      "year": "2015",
      "venue": "Nature",
      "tags": [
        "rl"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "krizhevskyAlexNet2012"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
        "christianoRLHF2017",
        "lillicrapDDPG2015",
        "mnihA3C_2016",
        "schulmanPPO2017",
        "schulmanTRPO2015",
        "silverAlphaGo2016"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@mnihDQN2015.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "mnihDQN2015",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 25,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 4,
            "tool_call": 21
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Improved Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models",
      "graph_label": "Improved DDPM",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Alex Nichol",
        "Prafulla Dhariwal"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "generative",
        "diffusion"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
        "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "luDPMSolver2022",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "zhangControlNet2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@nicholImprovedDDPM2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 24,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "tool_call": 22
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "WaveNet: A Generative Model for Raw Audio",
      "graph_label": "WaveNet",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Aäron van den Oord",
        "Sander Dieleman",
        "Heiga Zen",
        "Karen Simonyan",
        "Oriol Vinyals",
        "Alex Graves",
        "Nal Kalchbrenner",
        "Andrew Senior",
        "Koray Kavukcuoglu"
      ],
      "year": "2016",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "generative",
        "sequence",
        "cnn"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [],
      "further_papers": [
        "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
        "radfordWhisper2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@oordWaveNet2016.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "oordWaveNet2016",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 4,
          "proposed_count": 4,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 4,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "oordWaveNet2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@baevskiWav2Vec2_2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@baevskiWav2Vec2_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "oordWaveNet2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "oordWaveNet2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hoVideoDiffusion2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hoVideoDiffusion2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "oordWaveNet2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "radfordWhisper2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordWhisper2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordWhisper2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 29,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 29
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Training Language Models to Follow Instructions with Human Feedback",
      "graph_label": "InstructGPT",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Long Ouyang",
        "Jeff Wu"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "rlhf",
        "finetuning"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "chenCodex2021",
        "christianoRLHF2017",
        "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
        "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
        "radfordGPT2_2019",
        "raffelT5_2020",
        "schulmanPPO2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
        "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
        "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
        "rafailovDPO2023",
        "shaoGRPO2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@ouyangInstructGPT2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 16
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Scalable Diffusion Models with Transformers",
      "graph_label": "Scalable Diffusion Models with",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "William Peebles",
        "Saining Xie"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "ICCV",
      "tags": [
        "diffusion",
        "transformer",
        "generative"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "dosovitskiyViT2020",
        "heMAE2021",
        "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "luDPMSolver2022",
        "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
        "zhangControlNet2023"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "songConsistencyModels2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@peeblesDiT2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 8,
          "proposed_count": 8,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 5,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@albergoStochasticInterpolants2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@albergoStochasticInterpolants2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "karrasEDM2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@karrasEDM2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@karrasEDM2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@dosovitskiyViT2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 21,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 21
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "RWKV: Reinventing RNNs for the Transformer Era",
      "graph_label": "RWKV",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Bo Peng",
        "Eric Alcaide",
        "Quentin Anthony",
        "Alon Albalak",
        "Samuel Arcadinho",
        "Stella Biderman",
        "Huanqi Cao",
        "et al."
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "EMNLP Findings",
      "tags": [
        "sequence",
        "efficiency"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "hochreiterLSTM1997",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "guMamba2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@pengRWKV2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "pengRWKV2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "pengRWKV2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hochreiterLSTM1997]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hochreiterLSTM1997]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "pengRWKV2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 25,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 25
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "GloVe: Global Vectors for Word Representation",
      "graph_label": "GloVe",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jeffrey Pennington",
        "Richard Socher",
        "Christopher D. Manning"
      ],
      "year": "2014",
      "venue": "EMNLP",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "embeddings"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "mikolovWord2vec2013"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "petersELMo2018",
        "radfordGPT2018"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@penningtonGloVe2014.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "penningtonGloVe2014",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "penningtonGloVe2014",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "devlinBERT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@devlinBERT2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@devlinBERT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "penningtonGloVe2014",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "petersELMo2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@petersELMo2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@petersELMo2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "penningtonGloVe2014",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "radfordGPT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordGPT2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordGPT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 16
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Deep Contextualized Word Representations",
      "graph_label": "ELMo",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Matthew E. Peters",
        "Mark Neumann"
      ],
      "year": "2018",
      "venue": "NAACL",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "embeddings",
        "pretraining"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "choGRU2014",
        "hochreiterLSTM1997",
        "mikolovWord2vec2013",
        "penningtonGloVe2014"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "radfordGPT2018",
        "radfordGPT2_2019",
        "raffelT5_2020"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@petersELMo2018.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "petersELMo2018",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "petersELMo2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "petersELMo2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "devlinBERT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@devlinBERT2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@devlinBERT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "petersELMo2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "radfordGPT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordGPT2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordGPT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 16,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 13
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Grokking: Generalization Beyond Overfitting on Small Algorithmic Datasets",
      "graph_label": "Grokking",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Alethea Power",
        "Yuri Burda",
        "Harri Edwards",
        "Igor Babuschkin",
        "Vedant Misra"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "ICLR Workshop",
      "tags": [
        "foundations",
        "reasoning"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
        "loshchilovAdamW2019",
        "srivastavaDropout2014",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@powerGrokking2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "powerGrokking2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "powerGrokking2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "loshchilovAdamW2019",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@loshchilovAdamW2019]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@loshchilovAdamW2019]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "powerGrokking2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@srivastavaDropout2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@srivastavaDropout2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "powerGrokking2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Learning Transferable Visual Models from Natural Language Supervision",
      "graph_label": "CLIP",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Alec Radford",
        "Jong Wook Kim"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "multimodal",
        "vlm",
        "pretraining"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "dosovitskiyViT2020",
        "grillBYOL2020",
        "liuSwinTransformer2021"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "caronDINO2021",
        "chenSimCLR2020",
        "kirillovSAM2023",
        "liBLIP2_2023",
        "rameshDALLE2021",
        "wuNExTGPT2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@radfordCLIP2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 23,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 5,
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Unsupervised Representation Learning with Deep Convolutional Generative Adversarial Networks",
      "graph_label": "DCGAN",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Alec Radford",
        "Luke Metz",
        "Soumith Chintala"
      ],
      "year": "2015",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "generative",
        "gan",
        "vision"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "goodfellowGAN2014",
        "krizhevskyAlexNet2012"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "karrasStyleGAN2019"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@radfordDCGAN2015.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "radfordDCGAN2015",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 3,
            "tool_call": 15
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Improving Language Understanding by Generative Pre-Training",
      "graph_label": "GPT",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Alec Radford",
        "Karthik Narasimhan"
      ],
      "year": "2018",
      "venue": "OpenAI",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "transformer",
        "pretraining"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "penningtonGloVe2014",
        "petersELMo2018",
        "sennrichBPE2016",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "radfordGPT2_2019",
        "raffelT5_2020"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@radfordGPT2018.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "radfordGPT2018",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "radfordGPT2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "radfordGPT2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "devlinBERT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@devlinBERT2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@devlinBERT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "radfordGPT2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "raffelT5_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@raffelT5_2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@raffelT5_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 13,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "tool_call": 11
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Language Models are Unsupervised Multitask Learners",
      "graph_label": "GPT-2",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Alec Radford",
        "Jeffrey Wu"
      ],
      "year": "2019",
      "venue": "OpenAI",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "transformer",
        "pretraining"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "petersELMo2018",
        "radfordGPT2018",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
        "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
        "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@radfordGPT2_2019.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hoffmannChinchilla2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hoffmannChinchilla2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "devlinBERT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@devlinBERT2018]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@devlinBERT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "petersELMo2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@petersELMo2018]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@petersELMo2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 21,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 3,
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Robust Speech Recognition via Large-Scale Weak Supervision",
      "graph_label": "Robust Speech Recognition via",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Alec Radford",
        "Jong Wook Kim",
        "Tao Xu",
        "Greg Brockman",
        "Christine McLeavey",
        "Ilya Sutskever"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "sequence",
        "pretraining",
        "scaling"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
        "oordWaveNet2016"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "luUnifiedIO2_2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@radfordWhisper2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "radfordWhisper2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "radfordWhisper2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "radfordWhisper2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 22,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 22
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Direct Preference Optimization: Your Language Model is Secretly a Reward Model",
      "graph_label": "Direct Preference Optimization",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Rafael Rafailov",
        "Archit Sharma",
        "Eric Mitchell",
        "Stefano Ermon",
        "Christopher D. Manning",
        "Chelsea Finn"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "rlhf",
        "rl"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
        "christianoRLHF2017",
        "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
        "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
        "schulmanPPO2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "shaoGRPO2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@rafailovDPO2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "rafailovDPO2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@christianoRLHF2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@christianoRLHF2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "rafailovDPO2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "rafailovDPO2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schulmanPPO2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schulmanPPO2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Exploring the Limits of Transfer Learning with a Unified Text-to-Text Transformer",
      "graph_label": "T5",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Colin Raffel",
        "Noam Shazeer",
        "Adam Roberts"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "JMLR",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "transformer",
        "pretraining"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "petersELMo2018",
        "radfordGPT2018",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
        "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
        "lewisRAG2020",
        "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@raffelT5_2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "raffelT5_2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 4,
          "proposed_count": 4,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "raffelT5_2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-06",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-06",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-06"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "raffelT5_2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-06",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hoffmannChinchilla2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-06",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hoffmannChinchilla2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-06"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "raffelT5_2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-06",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-06",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-06"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "raffelT5_2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "petersELMo2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-06",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-06",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@petersELMo2018]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-06",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@petersELMo2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-06"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Zero-Shot Text-to-Image Generation",
      "graph_label": "DALL-E",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Aditya Ramesh",
        "Mikhail Pavlov"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "multimodal",
        "generative",
        "vision"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "radfordCLIP2021",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "chameleonTeam2024",
        "liBLIP2_2023",
        "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@rameshDALLE2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "rameshDALLE2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "rameshDALLE2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "liBLIP2_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@liBLIP2_2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@liBLIP2_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "rameshDALLE2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 23,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 20
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "You Only Look Once: Unified, Real-Time Object Detection",
      "graph_label": "YOLO",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Joseph Redmon",
        "Santosh Divvala",
        "Ross Girshick",
        "Ali Farhadi"
      ],
      "year": "2016",
      "venue": "CVPR",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "detection"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "renFasterRCNN2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "heMaskRCNN2017"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@redmonYOLO2016.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "redmonYOLO2016",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 1,
          "proposed_count": 1,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 1,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "redmonYOLO2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "heMaskRCNN2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heMaskRCNN2017]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heMaskRCNN2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 14,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 12
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Faster R-CNN: Towards Real-Time Object Detection with Region Proposal Networks",
      "graph_label": "Faster R-CNN",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Shaoqing Ren",
        "Kaiming He",
        "Ross Girshick",
        "Jian Sun"
      ],
      "year": "2015",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "detection"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "krizhevskyAlexNet2012"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "redmonYOLO2016",
        "heMaskRCNN2017"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@renFasterRCNN2015.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "renFasterRCNN2015",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 22,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 3,
            "tool_call": 19
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "High-Resolution Image Synthesis with Latent Diffusion Models",
      "graph_label": "Latent Diffusion",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Robin Rombach",
        "Andreas Blattmann",
        "Dominik Lorenz"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "CVPR",
      "tags": [
        "generative",
        "diffusion",
        "vision"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
        "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "hintonDistillation2015",
        "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
        "kingmaVAE2013",
        "luDPMSolver2022",
        "rameshDALLE2021"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "wuNExTGPT2023",
        "zhangControlNet2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@rombachLatentDiffusion2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 23,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 20
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "U-Net: Convolutional Networks for Biomedical Image Segmentation",
      "graph_label": "U-Net",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Olaf Ronneberger",
        "Philipp Fischer",
        "Thomas Brox"
      ],
      "year": "2015",
      "venue": "MICCAI",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "segmentation",
        "cnn"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@ronnebergerUNet2015.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "ronnebergerUNet2015",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 13,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 11
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "The Perceptron: A Probabilistic Model for Information Storage and Organization in the Brain",
      "graph_label": "Perceptron",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Frank Rosenblatt"
      ],
      "year": "1958",
      "venue": "Psychological Review",
      "tags": [
        "foundations"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [],
      "further_papers": [
        "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@rosenblattPerceptron1958.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "rosenblattPerceptron1958",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 16
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Learning Representations by Back-propagating Errors",
      "graph_label": "Backprop",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "David E. Rumelhart",
        "Geoffrey E. Hinton",
        "Ronald J. Williams"
      ],
      "year": "1986",
      "venue": "Nature",
      "tags": [
        "foundations",
        "optimization"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "rosenblattPerceptron1958"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
        "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
        "hochreiterLSTM1997"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 3,
            "tool_call": 15
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Toolformer: Language Models Can Teach Themselves to Use Tools",
      "graph_label": "Toolformer",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Timo Schick",
        "Jane Dwivedi-Yu",
        "Roberto Dessì",
        "Roberta Raileanu",
        "Maria Lomeli",
        "Luke Zettlemoyer",
        "Nicola Cancedda",
        "Thomas Scialom"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "reasoning",
        "search"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "chenCodex2021",
        "lewisRAG2020",
        "yaoReAct2022"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "kwonvLLM2023",
        "luUnifiedIO2_2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@schickToolformer2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "schickToolformer2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "schickToolformer2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kwonvLLM2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kwonvLLM2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "schickToolformer2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Mastering Atari, Go, Chess and Shogi by Planning with a Learned Model",
      "graph_label": "Mastering Atari, Go, Chess",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Julian Schrittwieser",
        "Ioannis Antonoglou",
        "Thomas Hubert",
        "Karen Simonyan",
        "Laurent Sifre",
        "Simon Schmitt",
        "Arthur Guez",
        "Edward Lockhart",
        "Demis Hassabis",
        "Thore Graepel",
        "Timothy Lillicrap",
        "David Silver"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "Nature",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "search",
        "generative"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
        "haWorldModels2018",
        "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
        "silverAlphaZero2018"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
        "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
        "yaoToT2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@schrittwieserMuZero2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 1,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV2_2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV2_2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "silverAlphaZero2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@silverAlphaZero2018]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@silverAlphaZero2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 20
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Proximal Policy Optimization Algorithms",
      "graph_label": "PPO",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "John Schulman",
        "Filip Wolski",
        "Prafulla Dhariwal"
      ],
      "year": "2017",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "policy"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "christianoRLHF2017",
        "mnihDQN2015",
        "schulmanTRPO2015",
        "silverAlphaZero2018"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "christianoRLHF2017",
        "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
        "rafailovDPO2023",
        "shaoGRPO2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@schulmanPPO2017.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 1,
          "proposed_count": 1,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "schulmanPPO2017",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@christianoRLHF2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@christianoRLHF2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Trust Region Policy Optimization",
      "graph_label": "Trust Region Policy Optimization",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "John Schulman",
        "Sergey Levine",
        "Philipp Moritz",
        "Michael I. Jordan",
        "Pieter Abbeel"
      ],
      "year": "2015",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "policy"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "lillicrapDDPG2015",
        "mnihA3C_2016",
        "mnihDQN2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "haarnojaSAC2018",
        "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
        "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
        "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
        "lillicrapDDPG2015",
        "mnihA3C_2016",
        "schulmanPPO2017"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@schulmanTRPO2015.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 8,
          "proposed_count": 8,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 5,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "haarnojaSAC2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@haarnojaSAC2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@haarnojaSAC2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV1_2019]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV1_2019]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV2_2021]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV2_2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@hafnerDreamerV3_2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@hafnerDreamerV3_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schulmanPPO2017]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schulmanPPO2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@lillicrapDDPG2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@lillicrapDDPG2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "mnihA3C_2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@mnihA3C_2016]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@mnihA3C_2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "mnihDQN2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@mnihDQN2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@mnihDQN2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 21,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 21
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Neural Machine Translation of Rare Words with Subword Units",
      "graph_label": "Neural Machine Translation Rare",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Rico Sennrich",
        "Barry Haddow",
        "Alexandra Birch"
      ],
      "year": "2016",
      "venue": "ACL",
      "tags": [
        "sequence",
        "foundations"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "bahdanauAttention2014",
        "choGRU2014",
        "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "radfordGPT2018",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@sennrichBPE2016.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 7,
          "proposed_count": 7,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 4,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "devlinBERT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@devlinBERT2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@devlinBERT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "radfordGPT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordGPT2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordGPT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "bahdanauAttention2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@bahdanauAttention2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@bahdanauAttention2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "choGRU2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@choGRU2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@choGRU2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@sutskeverSeq2Seq2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@sutskeverSeq2Seq2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 20
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "DeepSeekMath: Pushing the Limits of Mathematical Reasoning in Open Language Models",
      "graph_label": "DeepSeekMath",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Zhihong Shao",
        "Peiyi Wang",
        "Qihao Zhu",
        "Runxin Xu",
        "Junxiao Song",
        "Mingchuan Zhang",
        "Y. K. Li",
        "Y. Wu",
        "Daya Guo"
      ],
      "year": "2024",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "rlhf",
        "reasoning"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "jiangMixtral2024",
        "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
        "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
        "rafailovDPO2023",
        "schulmanPPO2017",
        "weiCoT2022",
        "yaoToT2023"
      ],
      "further_papers": [],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@shaoGRPO2024.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 5,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ouyangInstructGPT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "rafailovDPO2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rafailovDPO2023]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rafailovDPO2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schulmanPPO2017]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schulmanPPO2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "weiCoT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@weiCoT2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@weiCoT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 22,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 22
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Mastering the Game of Go with Deep Neural Networks and Tree Search",
      "graph_label": "AlphaGo",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "David Silver",
        "Aja Huang"
      ],
      "year": "2016",
      "venue": "Nature",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "search"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "mnihDQN2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "christianoRLHF2017",
        "silverAlphaZero2018"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@silverAlphaGo2016.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "silverAlphaGo2016",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 25,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "tool_call": 23
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "A General Reinforcement Learning Algorithm that Masters Chess, Shogi, and Go through Self-Play",
      "graph_label": "AlphaZero",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "David Silver",
        "Thomas Hubert"
      ],
      "year": "2018",
      "venue": "Science",
      "tags": [
        "rl",
        "search"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "silverAlphaGo2016"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "christianoRLHF2017",
        "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
        "schulmanPPO2017"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@silverAlphaZero2018.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "silverAlphaZero2018",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "silverAlphaZero2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@christianoRLHF2017]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@christianoRLHF2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "silverAlphaZero2018",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schulmanPPO2017]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schulmanPPO2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 17,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 15
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Very Deep Convolutional Networks for Large-Scale Image Recognition",
      "graph_label": "VGG",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Karen Simonyan",
        "Andrew Zisserman"
      ],
      "year": "2014",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "cnn"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
        "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
        "srivastavaDropout2014"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
        "heKaimingInit2015",
        "huangDenseNet2017",
        "szegedyGoogLeNet2015"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 4,
          "proposed_count": 4,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 2,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "huangDenseNet2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@huangDenseNet2017]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@huangDenseNet2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@srivastavaDropout2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@srivastavaDropout2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 15,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "tool_call": 13
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Consistency Models",
      "graph_label": "Consistency Models",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Yang Song",
        "Prafulla Dhariwal",
        "Mark Chen",
        "Ilya Sutskever"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "diffusion",
        "generative",
        "efficiency"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
        "hintonDistillation2015",
        "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
        "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
        "luDPMSolver2022",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "songScoreSDE2020",
        "zhangControlNet2023"
      ],
      "further_papers": [],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@songConsistencyModels2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 1,
          "proposed_count": 1,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "songConsistencyModels2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songScoreSDE2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songScoreSDE2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 22,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 22
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Score-Based Generative Modeling through Stochastic Differential Equations",
      "graph_label": "Score SDE",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Yang Song",
        "Jascha Sohl-Dickstein",
        "Diederik P. Kingma"
      ],
      "year": "2020",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "generative",
        "diffusion"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "dinhNVP2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
        "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
        "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
        "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
        "luDPMSolver2022",
        "songConsistencyModels2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@songScoreSDE2020.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 1,
          "proposed_count": 1,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 16
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Dropout: A Simple Way to Prevent Neural Networks from Overfitting",
      "graph_label": "Dropout",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Nitish Srivastava",
        "Geoffrey Hinton"
      ],
      "year": "2014",
      "venue": "JMLR",
      "tags": [
        "optimization",
        "regularization"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "goodfellowGAN2014",
        "krizhevskyAlexNet2012"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
        "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
        "hintonDistillation2015",
        "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
        "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
        "powerGrokking2022",
        "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@srivastavaDropout2014.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "srivastavaDropout2014",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "srivastavaDropout2014",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "srivastavaDropout2014",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@goodfellowGAN2014]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@goodfellowGAN2014]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 20,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 1,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "RoFormer: Enhanced Transformer with Rotary Position Embedding",
      "graph_label": "RoFormer",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jianlin Su",
        "Yu Lu",
        "Shengfeng Pan",
        "Bo Wen",
        "Yunfeng Liu"
      ],
      "year": "2021",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "transformer",
        "attention",
        "nlp"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "daoFlashAttention2022",
        "guMamba2023",
        "touvronLLaMA2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@suRoFormer2021.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "suRoFormer2021",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "suRoFormer2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "daoFlashAttention2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-12",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-12",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@daoFlashAttention2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-12",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@daoFlashAttention2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-12"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "suRoFormer2021",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "guMamba2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-12",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-12",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@guMamba2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-12",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@guMamba2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-12"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "suRoFormer2021",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "devlinBERT2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-12",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-12",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@devlinBERT2018]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-12",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@devlinBERT2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-12"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 21,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 21
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Sequence to Sequence Learning with Neural Networks",
      "graph_label": "Seq2Seq",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Ilya Sutskever",
        "Oriol Vinyals",
        "Quoc V. Le"
      ],
      "year": "2014",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "sequence"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "hochreiterLSTM1997"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "bahdanauAttention2014",
        "choGRU2014",
        "sennrichBPE2016",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@sutskeverSeq2Seq2014.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 1,
          "proposed_count": 1,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 1,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 14,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "tool_call": 12
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Going Deeper with Convolutions",
      "graph_label": "GoogLeNet",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Christian Szegedy",
        "Wei Liu",
        "Yangqing Jia"
      ],
      "year": "2015",
      "venue": "CVPR",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "cnn"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
        "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
        "heKaimingInit2015",
        "huangDenseNet2017",
        "tanEfficientNet2019"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@szegedyGoogLeNet2015.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 3,
          "proposed_count": 3,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@heDeepResidualLearning2016]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "huangDenseNet2017",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@huangDenseNet2017]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@huangDenseNet2017]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "tanEfficientNet2019",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-05",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-05",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@tanEfficientNet2019]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-05",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@tanEfficientNet2019]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-05"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 22,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 19
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "EfficientNet: Rethinking Model Scaling for Convolutional Neural Networks",
      "graph_label": "EfficientNet",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Mingxing Tan",
        "Quoc V. Le"
      ],
      "year": "2019",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "vision",
        "cnn",
        "efficiency"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
        "heKaimingInit2015",
        "huangDenseNet2017",
        "szegedyGoogLeNet2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@tanEfficientNet2019.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "tanEfficientNet2019",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 17,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "metadata": 1,
            "tool_call": 14
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "LLaMA: Open and Efficient Foundation Language Models",
      "graph_label": "LLaMA",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Hugo Touvron",
        "Thibaut Lavril",
        "Gautier Izacard",
        "Xavier Martinet",
        "Marie-Anne Lachaux",
        "Timothée Lacroix",
        "Baptiste Rozière",
        "Naman Goyal",
        "Eric Hambro",
        "Faisal Azhar",
        "Aurelien Rodriguez",
        "Armand Joulin",
        "Edouard Grave",
        "Guillaume Lample"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "arXiv",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "scaling",
        "pretraining"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
        "suRoFormer2021"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "jiangMixtral2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@touvronLLaMA2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "touvronLLaMA2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 24,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 24
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Instance Normalization: The Missing Ingredient for Fast Stylization",
      "graph_label": "InstanceNorm",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Dmitry Ulyanov",
        "Andrea Vedaldi",
        "Victor Lempitsky"
      ],
      "year": "2017",
      "venue": "",
      "tags": [
        "normalization",
        "vision"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "wuGroupNormalization2018"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@ulyanovInstanceNormalizationMissing2017.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "ulyanovInstanceNormalizationMissing2017",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 2,
          "proposed_count": 2,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 1,
            "further_papers": 1,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "ulyanovInstanceNormalizationMissing2017",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-04-12",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-04",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@wuGroupNormalization2018]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-04",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@wuGroupNormalization2018]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-04-12"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "ulyanovInstanceNormalizationMissing2017",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-04",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-04",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-04",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-04"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 17,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "metadata": 1,
            "pdf_text": 2,
            "proposal_relation": 1,
            "tool_call": 13
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Attention Is All You Need",
      "graph_label": "Transformer",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Ashish Vaswani",
        "Noam Shazeer",
        "Niki Parmar"
      ],
      "year": "2017",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "transformer",
        "attention"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "baLayerNormalization2016",
        "bahdanauAttention2014",
        "choGRU2014",
        "sennrichBPE2016",
        "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
        "daoFlashAttention2022",
        "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
        "devlinBERT2018",
        "dosovitskiyViT2020",
        "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
        "guMamba2023",
        "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
        "huLoRA2021",
        "jiangMixtral2024",
        "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
        "pengRWKV2023",
        "powerGrokking2022",
        "radfordGPT2018",
        "radfordGPT2_2019",
        "raffelT5_2020",
        "rameshDALLE2021"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 22,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 8,
            "tool_call": 14
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Graph Attention Networks",
      "graph_label": "Graph Attention Networks",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Petar Veličković",
        "Guillem Cucurull",
        "Arantxa Casanova",
        "Adriana Romero",
        "Pietro Liò",
        "Yoshua Bengio"
      ],
      "year": "2018",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "graph",
        "attention"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "kipfGCN2017",
        "hamiltonGraphSAGE2017",
        "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@velickovicGAT2018.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "velickovicGAT2018",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Chain-of-Thought Prompting Elicits Reasoning in Large Language Models",
      "graph_label": "CoT",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Jason Wei",
        "Xuezhi Wang"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "nlp",
        "reasoning"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
        "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
        "shaoGRPO2024",
        "yaoReAct2022",
        "yaoToT2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@weiCoT2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "weiCoT2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 16,
          "section_count": 6,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Further Research",
            "Prior Papers",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "canonical_relation": 2,
            "tool_call": 14
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Group Normalization",
      "graph_label": "GroupNorm",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Yuxin Wu",
        "Kaiming He"
      ],
      "year": "2018",
      "venue": "",
      "tags": [
        "normalization",
        "vision"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
        "baLayerNormalization2016",
        "ulyanovInstanceNormalizationMissing2017"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@wuGroupNormalization2018.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 0,
          "proposed_count": 0,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 0,
            "further_papers": 0,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": []
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 15,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 15
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "NExT-GPT: Any-to-Any Multimodal LLM",
      "graph_label": "NExT-GPT",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Shengqiong Wu",
        "Hao Fei",
        "Leigang Qu",
        "Wei Ji",
        "Tat-Seng Chua"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "ICML",
      "tags": [
        "multimodal",
        "generative",
        "vlm"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "alayracFlamingo2022",
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "kirillovSAM2023",
        "liBLIP2_2023",
        "radfordCLIP2021",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "chameleonTeam2024",
        "luUnifiedIO2_2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@wuNExTGPT2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 7,
          "proposed_count": 7,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 5,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@chameleonTeam2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@chameleonTeam2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@luUnifiedIO2_2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@alayracFlamingo2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "liBLIP2_2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@liBLIP2_2023]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@liBLIP2_2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@radfordCLIP2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@radfordCLIP2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-07",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-07",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-07"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 24,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 24
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "ReAct: Synergizing Reasoning and Acting in Language Models",
      "graph_label": "ReAct",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Shunyu Yao",
        "Jeffrey Zhao",
        "Dian Yu",
        "Nan Du",
        "Izhak Shafran",
        "Karthik Narasimhan",
        "Yuan Cao"
      ],
      "year": "2022",
      "venue": "ICLR",
      "tags": [
        "reasoning",
        "policy"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "brownGPT3_2020",
        "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
        "weiCoT2022"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "schickToolformer2023",
        "yaoToT2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@yaoReAct2022.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "yaoReAct2022",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 5,
          "proposed_count": 5,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 2,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "yaoReAct2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "schickToolformer2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schickToolformer2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schickToolformer2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "yaoReAct2022",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "yaoToT2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@yaoToT2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@yaoToT2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "yaoReAct2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@brownGPT3_2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@brownGPT3_2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "yaoReAct2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kojimaZeroShotCoT2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kojimaZeroShotCoT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "yaoReAct2022",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "weiCoT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@weiCoT2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@weiCoT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 17,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 17
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Tree of Thoughts: Deliberate Problem Solving with Large Language Models",
      "graph_label": "Tree Thoughts",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Shunyu Yao",
        "Dian Yu",
        "Jeffrey Zhao",
        "Izhak Shafran",
        "Thomas L. Griffiths",
        "Yuan Cao",
        "Karthik Narasimhan"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "NeurIPS",
      "tags": [
        "reasoning",
        "search"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
        "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
        "weiCoT2022",
        "yaoReAct2022"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "kwonvLLM2023",
        "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
        "shaoGRPO2024"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@yaoToT2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "yaoToT2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 6,
          "proposed_count": 6,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 3,
            "further_papers": 3,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "yaoToT2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kwonvLLM2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kwonvLLM2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "yaoToT2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@lightmanProcessSupervision2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@lightmanProcessSupervision2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "yaoToT2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@shaoGRPO2024]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@shaoGRPO2024]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "yaoToT2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@kojimaZeroShotCoT2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@kojimaZeroShotCoT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "yaoToT2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@schrittwieserMuZero2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@schrittwieserMuZero2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "yaoToT2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "weiCoT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@weiCoT2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@weiCoT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 19,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 19
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "title": "Adding Conditional Control to Text-to-Image Diffusion Models",
      "graph_label": "Adding Conditional Control Text-to-Image",
      "status": "reviewed",
      "paper_type": "empirical",
      "authors": [
        "Lvmin Zhang",
        "Anyi Rao",
        "Maneesh Agrawala"
      ],
      "year": "2023",
      "venue": "ICCV",
      "tags": [
        "diffusion",
        "generative",
        "vision"
      ],
      "prior_papers": [
        "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
        "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
        "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
        "rombachLatentDiffusion2022"
      ],
      "further_papers": [
        "karrasEDM2022",
        "luDPMSolver2022",
        "peeblesDiT2022",
        "songConsistencyModels2023"
      ],
      "path": "/opt/buildhome/repo/RoyalRoad/vault/Papers/@zhangControlNet2023.md",
      "visibility": "visible",
      "citekey": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "inspection": {
        "canonical_authority": "frontmatter",
        "relation_records": {
          "count": 8,
          "proposed_count": 8,
          "applied_count": 0,
          "rejected_count": 0,
          "by_relation": {
            "prior_papers": 4,
            "further_papers": 4,
            "related": 0
          },
          "records": [
            {
              "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "karrasEDM2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@karrasEDM2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@karrasEDM2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "luDPMSolver2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@luDPMSolver2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@luDPMSolver2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@peeblesDiT2022]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@peeblesDiT2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
              "relation": "further_papers",
              "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "further_papers",
              "why": "Cited as further papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] as further papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@songConsistencyModels2023]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@nicholImprovedDDPM2021]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
              "relation": "prior_papers",
              "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
              "lifecycle": "proposed",
              "authority": "sidecar",
              "canonical": false,
              "canonical_source": "frontmatter",
              "created_at": "2026-06-08",
              "updated_at": "2026-06-08",
              "candidate_status": "active",
              "stale": false,
              "score": 60,
              "confidence": 0.6,
              "direction_confidence": 0.0,
              "direction": "prior_papers",
              "why": "Cited as prior papers in AI review prose",
              "evidence_summary": "AI review references [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] as prior papers",
              "generator_version": "ai-review-agent",
              "last_suggested_at": "2026-06-07",
              "origins": [
                "ai-review-citation"
              ],
              "reasons": [
                "Wikilink [[@rombachLatentDiffusion2022]] appeared in AI-generated section"
              ],
              "evidence": [],
              "history": [
                {
                  "lifecycle": "proposed",
                  "changed_at": "2026-06-08"
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        "review_evidence": {
          "receipt_count": 18,
          "section_count": 4,
          "sections": [
            "Currently Used Methods",
            "Evaluation",
            "Problem",
            "Proposed Method"
          ],
          "source_type_counts": {
            "tool_call": 18
          }
        }
      }
    }
  ],
  "edges": [
    {
      "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "target": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "target": "ronnebergerUNet2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "target": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "target": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "target": "dinhNVP2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "target": "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "target": "kingmaVAE2013",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "target": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "target": "dinhNVP2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "target": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "target": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "dinhNVP2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "ronnebergerUNet2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "target": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
      "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
      "target": "kingmaVAE2013",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
      "target": "mildenhallNeRF2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
      "target": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "radfordWhisper2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "raffelT5_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "target": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "target": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "target": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baLayerNormalization2016",
      "target": "choGRU2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baLayerNormalization2016",
      "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baLayerNormalization2016",
      "target": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "sync-backfill",
        "origin": "maintain-vault",
        "recorded_at": "2026-04-11"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "sync-backfill",
      "provenance_origin": "maintain-vault"
    },
    {
      "source": "baLayerNormalization2016",
      "target": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
      "target": "oordWaveNet2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
      "target": "radfordWhisper2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "bahdanauAttention2014",
      "target": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "bahdanauAttention2014",
      "target": "choGRU2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "bahdanauAttention2014",
      "target": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "bahdanauAttention2014",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "target": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "target": "weiCoT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "target": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "target": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "target": "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "target": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "target": "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "target": "mikolovWord2vec2013",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "petersELMo2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "radfordGPT2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "raffelT5_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "chenCodex2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "huLoRA2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "weiCoT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "target": "yaoReAct2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "carionDETR2020",
      "target": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "carionDETR2020",
      "target": "renFasterRCNN2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "carionDETR2020",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "carionDETR2020",
      "target": "caronDINO2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "carionDETR2020",
      "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "carionDETR2020",
      "target": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "caronDINO2021",
      "target": "carionDETR2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "caronDINO2021",
      "target": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "caronDINO2021",
      "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "caronDINO2021",
      "target": "grillBYOL2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "caronDINO2021",
      "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "caronDINO2021",
      "target": "heMAE2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "caronDINO2021",
      "target": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "caronDINO2021",
      "target": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "target": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "target": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "target": "lewisRAG2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "target": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "target": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenCodex2021",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenCodex2021",
      "target": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenCodex2021",
      "target": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenCodex2021",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenCodex2021",
      "target": "schickToolformer2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "target": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "target": "mnihDQN2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "target": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "target": "kingmaAdam2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "target": "caronDINO2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "target": "grillBYOL2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "target": "heMAE2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "choGRU2014",
      "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "choGRU2014",
      "target": "mikolovWord2vec2013",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "choGRU2014",
      "target": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "choGRU2014",
      "target": "bahdanauAttention2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "choGRU2014",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "choGRU2014",
      "target": "haWorldModels2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "choGRU2014",
      "target": "petersELMo2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "choGRU2014",
      "target": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "choGRU2014",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "target": "mnihDQN2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "target": "silverAlphaGo2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "target": "silverAlphaZero2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "target": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "target": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "target": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "daoFlashAttention2022",
      "target": "suRoFormer2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "daoFlashAttention2022",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "daoFlashAttention2022",
      "target": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "target": "daoFlashAttention2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "target": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
      "target": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
      "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
      "target": "huLoRA2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
      "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
      "target": "frantarGPTQ2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "choGRU2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "penningtonGloVe2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "petersELMo2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "radfordGPT2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "huLoRA2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "raffelT5_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "devlinBERT2018",
      "target": "suRoFormer2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "oordWaveNet2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dinhNVP2017",
      "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dinhNVP2017",
      "target": "kingmaAdam2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dinhNVP2017",
      "target": "kingmaVAE2013",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dinhNVP2017",
      "target": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dinhNVP2017",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dinhNVP2017",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dinhNVP2017",
      "target": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dinhNVP2017",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "target": "carionDETR2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "target": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "target": "caronDINO2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "target": "heMAE2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "target": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "target": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "target": "raffelT5_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "target": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "target": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "target": "frantarGPTQ2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "target": "powerGrokking2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "frantarGPTQ2022",
      "target": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "frantarGPTQ2022",
      "target": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "frantarGPTQ2022",
      "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "target": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "target": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "target": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "target": "dinhNVP2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "target": "karrasStyleGAN2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "target": "radfordDCGAN2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "grillBYOL2020",
      "target": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "grillBYOL2020",
      "target": "caronDINO2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "grillBYOL2020",
      "target": "heMAE2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "grillBYOL2020",
      "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "guMamba2023",
      "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "guMamba2023",
      "target": "pengRWKV2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "guMamba2023",
      "target": "suRoFormer2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "guMamba2023",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "guS4_2021",
      "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "guS4_2021",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "guS4_2021",
      "target": "guMamba2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "haWorldModels2018",
      "target": "choGRU2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haWorldModels2018",
      "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haWorldModels2018",
      "target": "kingmaVAE2013",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haWorldModels2018",
      "target": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haWorldModels2018",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haWorldModels2018",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haWorldModels2018",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haWorldModels2018",
      "target": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "target": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "target": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "target": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "target": "haWorldModels2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "target": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "target": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "target": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "target": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "target": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "target": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "target": "haWorldModels2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "target": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "target": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "target": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "target": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "target": "haWorldModels2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "target": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "target": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "target": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hamiltonGraphSAGE2017",
      "target": "kipfGCN2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "hamiltonGraphSAGE2017",
      "target": "velickovicGAT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "target": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "target": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "sync-backfill",
        "origin": "maintain-vault",
        "recorded_at": "2026-04-11"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "sync-backfill",
      "provenance_origin": "maintain-vault"
    },
    {
      "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "target": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "target": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "target": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "target": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "target": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "target": "huangDenseNet2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "target": "tanEfficientNet2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "target": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "target": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "target": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "target": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "target": "huangDenseNet2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "target": "tanEfficientNet2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMAE2021",
      "target": "caronDINO2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMAE2021",
      "target": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMAE2021",
      "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMAE2021",
      "target": "grillBYOL2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMAE2021",
      "target": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMAE2021",
      "target": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMAE2021",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "target": "redmonYOLO2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "target": "renFasterRCNN2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "target": "carionDETR2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "target": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "target": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "heMoCo2020",
      "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "heMoCo2020",
      "target": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "heMoCo2020",
      "target": "grillBYOL2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
      "target": "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
      "target": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
      "target": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
      "target": "hintonDistillation2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hintonDistillation2015",
      "target": "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hintonDistillation2015",
      "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hintonDistillation2015",
      "target": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hintonDistillation2015",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hintonDistillation2015",
      "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "target": "oordWaveNet2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "target": "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "target": "choGRU2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "target": "guMamba2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "target": "haWorldModels2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "target": "pengRWKV2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "target": "petersELMo2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "target": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "target": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "target": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "target": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "target": "raffelT5_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "target": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "target": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "target": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "target": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "huLoRA2021",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "huLoRA2021",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "huLoRA2021",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "huLoRA2021",
      "target": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "huangDenseNet2017",
      "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "huangDenseNet2017",
      "target": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "huangDenseNet2017",
      "target": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "huangDenseNet2017",
      "target": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "huangDenseNet2017",
      "target": "tanEfficientNet2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "target": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "target": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "target": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "target": "baLayerNormalization2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "target": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "target": "ulyanovInstanceNormalizationMissing2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "target": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "target": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "target": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
      "target": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
      "target": "chenCodex2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
      "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasEDM2022",
      "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasStyleGAN2019",
      "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "karrasStyleGAN2019",
      "target": "radfordDCGAN2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kerblGaussianSplatting2023",
      "target": "mildenhallNeRF2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kingmaAdam2014",
      "target": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kingmaAdam2014",
      "target": "dinhNVP2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kingmaAdam2014",
      "target": "loshchilovAdamW2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kingmaVAE2013",
      "target": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kingmaVAE2013",
      "target": "dinhNVP2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kingmaVAE2013",
      "target": "haWorldModels2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kingmaVAE2013",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kipfGCN2017",
      "target": "hamiltonGraphSAGE2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "kipfGCN2017",
      "target": "velickovicGAT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "target": "caronDINO2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "target": "heMAE2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "target": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "target": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "target": "weiCoT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "target": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "target": "yaoReAct2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "target": "yaoToT2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "target": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "target": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "target": "mnihDQN2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "target": "radfordDCGAN2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "target": "renFasterRCNN2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "target": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "target": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "target": "frantarGPTQ2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "target": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "target": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "target": "schickToolformer2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "target": "yaoToT2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "target": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "target": "dettmersQLoRA2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "target": "rosenblattPerceptron1958",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "target": "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "target": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "target": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "target": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "target": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "target": "chenCodex2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "target": "hintonDistillation2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "target": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "target": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "leviathanSpeculativeDecoding2023",
      "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lewisRAG2020",
      "target": "raffelT5_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lewisRAG2020",
      "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lewisRAG2020",
      "target": "schickToolformer2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "target": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "target": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "target": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "target": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "target": "yaoToT2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "target": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "target": "mnihDQN2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "target": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "target": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "target": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "target": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "target": "dinhNVP2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "target": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "target": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "target": "caronDINO2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "target": "heMAE2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "target": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "target": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "loshchilovAdamW2019",
      "target": "kingmaAdam2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "loshchilovAdamW2019",
      "target": "powerGrokking2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "target": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "target": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "target": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "target": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "target": "radfordWhisper2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "target": "raffelT5_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "target": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "target": "schickToolformer2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "target": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mikolovWord2vec2013",
      "target": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mikolovWord2vec2013",
      "target": "choGRU2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mikolovWord2vec2013",
      "target": "penningtonGloVe2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mikolovWord2vec2013",
      "target": "petersELMo2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mildenhallNeRF2020",
      "target": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mildenhallNeRF2020",
      "target": "kerblGaussianSplatting2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "target": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "target": "mnihDQN2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "target": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "target": "haWorldModels2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "target": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihDQN2015",
      "target": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihDQN2015",
      "target": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihDQN2015",
      "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihDQN2015",
      "target": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihDQN2015",
      "target": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihDQN2015",
      "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihDQN2015",
      "target": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "mnihDQN2015",
      "target": "silverAlphaGo2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "target": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "target": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "target": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "target": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "oordWaveNet2016",
      "target": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "oordWaveNet2016",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "oordWaveNet2016",
      "target": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "oordWaveNet2016",
      "target": "radfordWhisper2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "chenCodex2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "raffelT5_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "heMAE2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "pengRWKV2023",
      "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "pengRWKV2023",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "pengRWKV2023",
      "target": "guMamba2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "penningtonGloVe2014",
      "target": "mikolovWord2vec2013",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "penningtonGloVe2014",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "penningtonGloVe2014",
      "target": "petersELMo2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "penningtonGloVe2014",
      "target": "radfordGPT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "petersELMo2018",
      "target": "choGRU2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "petersELMo2018",
      "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "petersELMo2018",
      "target": "mikolovWord2vec2013",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "petersELMo2018",
      "target": "penningtonGloVe2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "petersELMo2018",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "petersELMo2018",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "petersELMo2018",
      "target": "radfordGPT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "petersELMo2018",
      "target": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "petersELMo2018",
      "target": "raffelT5_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "powerGrokking2022",
      "target": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "powerGrokking2022",
      "target": "loshchilovAdamW2019",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "powerGrokking2022",
      "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "powerGrokking2022",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "target": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "target": "grillBYOL2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "target": "liuSwinTransformer2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "target": "caronDINO2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "target": "chenSimCLR2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "target": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "target": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "target": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "target": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordDCGAN2015",
      "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordDCGAN2015",
      "target": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordDCGAN2015",
      "target": "karrasStyleGAN2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2018",
      "target": "penningtonGloVe2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2018",
      "target": "petersELMo2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2018",
      "target": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2018",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2018",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2018",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2018",
      "target": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2018",
      "target": "raffelT5_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "target": "petersELMo2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "target": "radfordGPT2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "target": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "target": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordWhisper2022",
      "target": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordWhisper2022",
      "target": "oordWaveNet2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordWhisper2022",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "radfordWhisper2022",
      "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "target": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "target": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "target": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "raffelT5_2020",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "raffelT5_2020",
      "target": "petersELMo2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "raffelT5_2020",
      "target": "radfordGPT2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "raffelT5_2020",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "raffelT5_2020",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "raffelT5_2020",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "raffelT5_2020",
      "target": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "raffelT5_2020",
      "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "raffelT5_2020",
      "target": "lewisRAG2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "raffelT5_2020",
      "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "raffelT5_2020",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "target": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "redmonYOLO2016",
      "target": "renFasterRCNN2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "redmonYOLO2016",
      "target": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "renFasterRCNN2015",
      "target": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "renFasterRCNN2015",
      "target": "redmonYOLO2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "renFasterRCNN2015",
      "target": "heMaskRCNN2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionImplicitModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "hintonDistillation2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "kingmaVAE2013",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "target": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ronnebergerUNet2015",
      "target": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ronnebergerUNet2015",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ronnebergerUNet2015",
      "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rosenblattPerceptron1958",
      "target": "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986",
      "target": "rosenblattPerceptron1958",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986",
      "target": "bengioRepresentationLearning2013",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986",
      "target": "hintonDeepBeliefNets2006",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "rumelhartLearningRepresentationsBackpropagating1986",
      "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schickToolformer2023",
      "target": "chenCodex2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schickToolformer2023",
      "target": "lewisRAG2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schickToolformer2023",
      "target": "yaoReAct2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schickToolformer2023",
      "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schickToolformer2023",
      "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "target": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "target": "haWorldModels2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "target": "silverAlphaZero2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "target": "yaoToT2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "target": "mnihDQN2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "target": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "target": "silverAlphaZero2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "target": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "target": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "target": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "target": "mnihDQN2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "target": "haarnojaSAC2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV1_2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV2_2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "target": "hafnerDreamerV3_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "target": "lillicrapDDPG2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "target": "mnihA3C_2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "schulmanTRPO2015",
      "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "target": "bahdanauAttention2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "target": "choGRU2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "target": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "target": "radfordGPT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "target": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "target": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "target": "ouyangInstructGPT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "target": "rafailovDPO2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "target": "weiCoT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "target": "yaoToT2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "silverAlphaGo2016",
      "target": "mnihDQN2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "silverAlphaGo2016",
      "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "silverAlphaGo2016",
      "target": "silverAlphaZero2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "silverAlphaZero2018",
      "target": "silverAlphaGo2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "silverAlphaZero2018",
      "target": "christianoRLHF2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "silverAlphaZero2018",
      "target": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "silverAlphaZero2018",
      "target": "schulmanPPO2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "target": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "target": "lecunGradientbasedLearningApplied1998",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "target": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "target": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "target": "huangDenseNet2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "target": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "target": "hintonDistillation2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "target": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "target": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "target": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "target": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "target": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "target": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "DeepUnsupervisedLearningusing2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "dinhNVP2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "albergoStochasticInterpolants2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "dhariwalDiffusionBeatGANs2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "hoVideoDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "lipmanFlowMatching2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "liuRectifiedFlow2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "songScoreSDE2020",
      "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "target": "goodfellowGAN2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "target": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "target": "frankleLotteryTicket2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "target": "hintonDistillation2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "target": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "target": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "target": "powerGrokking2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "srivastavaDropout2014",
      "target": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "suRoFormer2021",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "suRoFormer2021",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "suRoFormer2021",
      "target": "daoFlashAttention2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "suRoFormer2021",
      "target": "guMamba2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "suRoFormer2021",
      "target": "touvronLLaMA2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
      "target": "hochreiterLSTM1997",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
      "target": "bahdanauAttention2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
      "target": "choGRU2014",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
      "target": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "target": "krizhevskyAlexNet2012",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "target": "simonyanVGGVeryDeep2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "target": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "target": "huangDenseNet2017",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "target": "tanEfficientNet2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "tanEfficientNet2019",
      "target": "heDeepResidualLearning2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "tanEfficientNet2019",
      "target": "heKaimingInit2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "tanEfficientNet2019",
      "target": "huangDenseNet2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "tanEfficientNet2019",
      "target": "szegedyGoogLeNet2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "touvronLLaMA2023",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "touvronLLaMA2023",
      "target": "hoffmannChinchilla2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "touvronLLaMA2023",
      "target": "suRoFormer2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "touvronLLaMA2023",
      "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "ulyanovInstanceNormalizationMissing2017",
      "target": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "ulyanovInstanceNormalizationMissing2017",
      "target": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "baLayerNormalization2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "bahdanauAttention2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "choGRU2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "sennrichBPE2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "sutskeverSeq2Seq2014",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "baevskiWav2Vec2_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "chenDecisionTransformer2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "daoFlashAttention2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "daoFlashAttention2_2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "devlinBERT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "dosovitskiyViT2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "fedusSwitchTransformer2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "guMamba2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "holtzmanNucleusSampling2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "huLoRA2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "jiangMixtral2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "kaplanScalingLaws2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "pengRWKV2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "powerGrokking2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "radfordGPT2018",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "radfordGPT2_2019",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "raffelT5_2020",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "target": "rameshDALLE2021",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "velickovicGAT2018",
      "target": "kipfGCN2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "velickovicGAT2018",
      "target": "hamiltonGraphSAGE2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "velickovicGAT2018",
      "target": "vaswaniAttentionAllNeed2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": false,
      "governance_status": "needs-reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "import-metadata",
        "origin": "import-note",
        "recorded_at": "2026-06-12"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "import-metadata",
      "provenance_origin": "import-note"
    },
    {
      "source": "weiCoT2022",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "weiCoT2022",
      "target": "baiConstitutionalAI2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "weiCoT2022",
      "target": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "weiCoT2022",
      "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "weiCoT2022",
      "target": "yaoReAct2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "weiCoT2022",
      "target": "yaoToT2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
      "target": "ioffeBatchNormalizationAccelerating2015",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "sync-backfill",
        "origin": "maintain-vault",
        "recorded_at": "2026-04-11"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "sync-backfill",
      "provenance_origin": "maintain-vault"
    },
    {
      "source": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
      "target": "baLayerNormalization2016",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "sync-backfill",
        "origin": "maintain-vault",
        "recorded_at": "2026-04-11"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "sync-backfill",
      "provenance_origin": "maintain-vault"
    },
    {
      "source": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
      "target": "ulyanovInstanceNormalizationMissing2017",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {
        "kind": "sync-backfill",
        "origin": "maintain-vault",
        "recorded_at": "2026-04-11"
      },
      "provenance_kind": "sync-backfill",
      "provenance_origin": "maintain-vault"
    },
    {
      "source": "wuGroupNormalization2018",
      "target": "GenerativeInverseDesignof2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "target": "alayracFlamingo2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "target": "kirillovSAM2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "target": "liBLIP2_2023",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "target": "radfordCLIP2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "target": "chameleonTeam2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "wuNExTGPT2023",
      "target": "luUnifiedIO2_2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "yaoReAct2022",
      "target": "brownGPT3_2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "yaoReAct2022",
      "target": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "yaoReAct2022",
      "target": "weiCoT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "yaoReAct2022",
      "target": "schickToolformer2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "yaoReAct2022",
      "target": "yaoToT2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "yaoToT2023",
      "target": "kojimaZeroShotCoT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "yaoToT2023",
      "target": "schrittwieserMuZero2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "yaoToT2023",
      "target": "weiCoT2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "yaoToT2023",
      "target": "yaoReAct2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "yaoToT2023",
      "target": "kwonvLLM2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "yaoToT2023",
      "target": "lightmanProcessSupervision2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "yaoToT2023",
      "target": "shaoGRPO2024",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "target": "ClassifierFreeDiffusionGuidance2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "target": "DenoisingDiffusionProbabilisticModels2020",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "target": "nicholImprovedDDPM2021",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "target": "rombachLatentDiffusion2022",
      "relation": "prior_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "further_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "target": "karrasEDM2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "target": "luDPMSolver2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "target": "peeblesDiT2022",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    },
    {
      "source": "zhangControlNet2023",
      "target": "songConsistencyModels2023",
      "relation": "further_papers",
      "kind": "canonical",
      "authority": "frontmatter",
      "target_exists": true,
      "reciprocal": true,
      "governance_status": "reciprocal",
      "reciprocal_relation": "prior_papers",
      "source_status": "reviewed",
      "target_status": "reviewed",
      "provenance": {},
      "provenance_kind": "",
      "provenance_origin": ""
    }
  ]
}